Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: VIDEO: Austin Rivers' Buzzer Beater Finishes Off UNC

From Our Editors

Updated throughout the day with quick takes from staff.

Ortiz, Ramirez Allegedly on 2003 PED List; It's Time To Just Release 'The List'

Counterpoint: Dan Levy argues against releasing the list

I know Moneyball is sort of out there in the world floating around as a movie that may or may not get made, but I'm proposing a different movie to studios. We'll call it The List. It will be a franchise loosely based on The Ring, in that once your name appears on The List, you melt right where you stand.

The latest names to appear on The List are Manny Ramirez and David Ortiz, according to the New York Times:

The information about Ramirez and Ortiz emerged through interviews with multiple lawyers and others connected to the pending litigation. The lawyers spoke anonymously because the testing information is under seal by a court order. The lawyers did not identify which drugs were detected.

OK, Ramirez is old news. He just served a 50-game suspension. Ortiz is one of those guys everyone has whispered about for a while just based on the precipitous drop in his production. The career narrative of marginal player to superstar of a World Series winner and back to marginal player usually sends up a red flag.

So fine. There's that. Two more names from the list that was supposed to be anonymous. Does anyone feel different -- save a few incredibly naïve members of Red Sox nation -- than they did 24 hours ago, or has your life marched on? I'm going to propose a wild idea based on cooperation between MLB and its players union, which means it's probably never going to work.

Release The List.

Look, it's time for this to happen. Remember how your mom always told you it's better to just rip the Band-Aid off rather than peel it slowly? Right now baseball isn't just getting the bandage removed slowly, it's also being skinned alive. The List is not just a giant ticking time bomb, it's like a Cold War-style stockpile of weapons just waiting to divert attention away from anything baseball-related back to steroids. Even if people don't care about the actual issue of steroids, they're still forced to hear about them.

The trading deadline is upon us. Where are Victor Martinez and Roy Halladay headed? That'd be neat to find out, but it's time for wall-to-wall revisionist history of Boston's World Series win, because that's obviously something that matters now.

What's the absolute worst that could happen? Unless Henry Aaron himself is on that list right next to Babe Ruth through the power of time travel, there isn't a name on that list that's going to matter at this point. The media would marvel at it for a week, there'd be a end-of-year retrospective that would touch on it, and then you know what? It'd be over.

I say all of this knowing that it will never happen because the union would never sell out the players like that for the good of MLB. So I'll see everyone back here in another few months when the next round of names drops from the least anonymous drug test list of all time.

This post originally appeared on the Sporting Blog. For more, see The Sporting Blog Archives.

Do you like this post?

Comments

Display:

Dead on! Stop this name-by-name release business, and just publish the whole thing. This has gone on long enough.

by weathersusa on Jul 30, 2009 1:33 PM EDT reply actions  

And when they finally release the list and punish the players on the list, release the names of the lawyers who were speaking "anonymously because the testing information is under seal by a court order" so they can be punished, too.

by dtalbott on Jul 30, 2009 2:41 PM EDT reply actions  

Yes!  This just makes no sense.  I would bet if someone on this list criticized Selig their name would be out next week.  Selig thought his big expensive investigation/report would end this… but it’s just bringing up more and more crap.

good article

by brooks36 on Jul 30, 2009 2:49 PM EDT reply actions  

I have said it since 2004… "It’s not just Bonds it’s the entire league, Bonds is just better then everyone else" fans said I had no proof.. My response was that I am a personal trainer and now have been since for 6 years and have seen it first hand for a long time especially with the football players high school- pro. 100% of them are taking some sort of ped. I have yet to meet one football player who is not taking a ped. NOT ONE! As for the major league baseball players I sat down 3 years ago with 3 of my buddies after our fantasy draft and a few beers we decided to take the entire MLB from 2003 .. 4 of us drafting 20 rounds, whoever gets the most right wins the 80 dollar pot all players who played in the majors that year are up for grabs these are the guys I drafted… Bonds, Sheffield, Clemens, Ortiz, Nevin, Percival, Nomar, Durazo, Salmon, Spezio, Thomas, Lee, Finley, Hafner, Galaraga, Mcgriff, Jeter, Pena, Posada and Juan gone.. Other notables I would have drafted would have been Pudge, Gilses, Stairs, Klesko, Sanders, Alou, Helton, V.Wells, Sexson, Chavez, T Clark, Boone, Schmidt, Dotel, Rivera, Alomar, Mesa, Thome, Wagner, Krod and Brown …..

by gntsfan24 on Jul 30, 2009 3:13 PM EDT reply actions  

They can’t release the list!  Neither the union nor MLB can do so without leaving themselves wide open to be sued by the players on the list who have not yet been exposed.  That’s the problem…both MLB and the Players Union promised confidentiality to the players if they cooperated with the 2003 testing.

by BradKT on Jul 30, 2009 3:20 PM EDT reply actions  

So now what?? You black ball Bonds for what?? using steroids? wow.. Since nothing Bonds did counts do you take away the Sox world series which we all know is not won without steroid users Is this a part of the curse?? Was it right to black ball Bonds when he had at least 2 years left as a DH It’s all a joke. Fans called for Bonds to be banned from the game and Giants fans were called crazy for cheering a "cheat" but again I promise just like Arod/Afraud or Manny or Sheffield or Pudge or Tejada or Giambi fans will love him as soon as he hits another home run.. DOUBLE STANDARDS??? Can someone explain to me just like Arod – how Pujols is clean  and going to "save baseball"  lets hear it ! because I will tell you your wrong with more then valid points and we can argue back and forth Cardinal fans..Tell me how the biggest strongest, best hitter in the league is the only one that hasn’t used steroids. Please people lets finally get real and admit that Gntsfan24 has been right all along. I love it.

by gntsfan24 on Jul 30, 2009 3:22 PM EDT reply actions  

    I agree with everybody else, release the names. Or better yet if the players still to be named would just come on down!! This dribbling out of a name here & there is the most cowardly thing I’ve seen yet. The sooner all this comes out in the open, the quicker MLB can get on down the road from this era. Also it would let the players who were ACTUALLY clean get out from under that umbrella of taint.

by Wildcat Blue 322 on Jul 30, 2009 3:23 PM EDT reply actions  

PAPPI On Roids? "Wow who would of thunk it? Didn’t  Pappi say when arod got caught, That players who get caught using roids should be ban from baseball? Well Big Roids Pappi what do you have to say now? can’t wait to hear from the big mounth schilling now!

by LA RAMS13 on Jul 30, 2009 4:42 PM EDT reply actions  

PAPPI On Roids? "Wow who would of thunk it? Didn’t  Pappi say when arod got caught, That players who get caught using roids should be ban from baseball? Well Big Roids Pappi what do you have to say now? can’t wait to hear from  schilling now!

by LA RAMS13 on Jul 30, 2009 4:43 PM EDT reply actions  

I’m just glad that baseball has been clean all of these days after the compiliation of the "list". I’m also glad that I just found out that the tooth fairy is real…and she’s freakin’ hot.

by buffetkiller on Jul 30, 2009 5:28 PM EDT reply actions  

What a surprise, the year they win their first world series, it turns out their two dominant batters were juiced. Another tainted Boston championship. they Must have attended the Belichek school of cheating.

by Yanks919 on Jul 30, 2009 6:34 PM EDT reply actions  

i wish this list would just become public so the whispering of players will stop, i mean most people could guess most of the names on that list..Ortiz was no shock at all

by bljay29 on Jul 30, 2009 6:41 PM EDT reply actions  

Albert Pujols? Is he the only power hitter to be clean.  I doubt it, but he has yet to be implicated.

by Respectall on Jul 30, 2009 6:56 PM EDT reply actions  

  MLB should come out and say we are going to release the list in a week, so that gives EVERYONE on the list to come clean. I gotta agree with what has been said earlier , ENOUGH of the name by name every couple of months . If you have released just a couple of "BIG NAMES" , then you should also be putting out the other names too.

by PhillyFan4Ever on Jul 30, 2009 6:59 PM EDT reply actions  

It’s nothing short of amazing how cavalier many of you are about the violation of a sealed document, guessing those who think this is a positive are the same geniuses who pissed all over the USA during these last 8 years of Bush/Ashcroft/Gonzalez civil-liberties violations with comments like ‘if you have nothing to hide, you shouldn’t mind the Government listening to your phone conversations, etc.’ The point being, YOU are the problem that needs to be cut out of society, not the solution you believe yourselves to be. The FELONY here is the release of these names, the coincidence that the released players happen to be prominent minorities who make serious coin and have already done what they will do to pad the wallets of their organizations. Will John Henry volunteer to take an assessed value for the Red Sox at a 2002 level, which is 100’s of millions of dollars below what it worth after Manny delivered the only two championships the Red Sox have seen or are likely to see in multiple generations? Will the ownership who wish to alter the salary structure volunteer to return every dime of profit from sales and turnstiles associated with Barry, Alex, Manny, Papi?The owners want an NFL style situation, where they hold all the leverage and pocket coin, regardless of franchise specific productivity and a free enterprise system where the player commands what his production and marketability demands will never allow this. The NFL has deliberately taken its product down, there is no comparison between the talent laden pre-cap era clubs like the Bears, ‘86 Giants, Cowboys, 49ers and the watered down ’system’ clubs in the post cap era, but the networks still sell ads and nobody seems to care, so the owners say ‘hurrah!’, but this is a system that has resulted in the premiere franchise of the era having its second biggest ‘star’ be the head coach for his ability to elevate role players and fit them into a team concept, which works a hell of a lot better when you don’t have to compete with a higher-revenue team who can spend what they MAKE on their own product.

by vagabondguru on Jul 30, 2009 7:19 PM EDT reply actions  

Is really anybody surprised at this……Pleas release all the names so we dont have to go through this crap every 3 months….What a joke……They should take alll state from these players and the teams they were on should loose the titles they won…I think its fair you have a one cheater on the field it should make it illegal and it should be an automatic forfeit………What a shame

by mart2007 on Jul 30, 2009 9:27 PM EDT reply actions  

Obviously the union didn’t protect A-rod, Big Papi, Manny, Bonds, Segui, and Grimsley from having their names revealed. So why should it focus on protecting the other 98 positive tests? I say just release the names so we can get this thing over with. ‘The List’ is like an annoying unrhythmic dripping faucet, with its ‘drip…drip….drip drip drip…drip….drip’ of names that are released every 2-3 months like clockwork. This only mean the next name will be released in time for the playoffs.

by CaliforniaKid on Jul 30, 2009 11:09 PM EDT reply actions  

Release the list and break the emotioal hold it has on true baseball fans.

by rocky o8 on Jul 31, 2009 11:41 AM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed