Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Kobe Bryant Isn't Up To Speed On Jeremy Lin, 'Linning'

From Our Editors

Updated throughout the day with quick takes from staff.

Shanoff's WUC: Tebow, Snead, Vick, Cox, Nets

Today's Calls: Tim Tebow vs. Matt Leinart, Tom Brady vs. Peyton Manning, Mike Vick vs. Wildcat, Bobby Cox vs. 2010, Kansas basketball vs. Kansas football, Rockies vs. Giants vs. Braves, Mark Cuban vs. Mikhail Prokhorov and More.

The Opening Pitch: Why do my Sporting News colleagues hate America?

Remember a few months ago when you were able to vote for SN's Athletes of the Decade? Your votes were right on:

• Albert Pujols (82-18 over A-Rod).

• Kobe Bryant (55-45 over Duncan).

• Tyler Hansbrough (66-34 over Jason Williams).

• Nicklas Lidstrom (55-45 over Brodeur).

• Jimmie Johnson (51-49 over Tony Stewart).

And Tim Tebow, with a landslide 79-21 win over Matt Leinart. ...

Wait: What's that you say? SN picked Leinart over Tebow? They nullified the overwhelming choice of the people?

Compounding the issue, they wrongly overturned the popular choice ... twice. They also picked Peyton Manning over Tom Brady, even though Brady (rightfully) earned 50 percent more votes than Peyton.

But back to Tebow: My colleagues' logic rests on two things -- Leinart's record as a starter, which inflates Leinart's role in that team winning percentage (especially given the equal success of his predecessors) and his role in putting USC on the map as a national power.

However, in three years (to Leinart's four), Tim Tebow has done everything notable on Leinart's resume -- national titles, Heismans, winning, program-building (plus a "living legend" status that SN acknowledges but discounts, even though it may be the BIGGEST factor).

But, wait! There's more: Tebow has still got a year to go, where his team is not only the favorite to win another national title, but he is also the leading contender to win another Heisman. Even putting Tebow's first three years against Leinart's four, Tebow's resume is superior.

That only affirms what the fans already knew; they saw the difference clearly enough to vote overwhelmingly -- and correctly -- for Tebow over Leinart. Unlike for the other players of the decade, my SN colleagues chose to dismiss that collective wisdom.

Vick Watch: "I was the Wildcat originator." Well, not quite. Vick didn't run the single-wing -- back in his prime, wouldn't THAT have been interesting? Rather than innovate, then-coach Jim Mora wanted to mash Vick into the West Coast Offense.

Vick resisted. Whether by self-motivated design or simply because he didn't bother to study the playbook, Vick made his name and his game with his legs -- and the rest of the league has finally caught on.

Vick's sentiment is awkwardly phrased, but right on: I think what has me so excited about his debut on Sunday is that he really does represent for the Wildcat -- if not the "originator" returning -- the next step in its evolution: A "real" QB who can run the formation.

CFB Tonight: (4) Ole Miss at South Carolina. No team's ranking is more inflated by preseason hype -- rather than this season's on-field results -- than the Rebels. This is their chance to make a "statement" -- or be exposed as overrated. Pick: Ole Miss

Feuds: SEC commish Mike Slive has had enough of the Kiffin-Meyer yapping. (Of course, given the terrific TV ratings for the Florida-Tennessee game -- in part, driven by the off-field rivalry-stoking by the coaches -- Slive can't be that bothered by it.)

Matt Barkley will be back at starting QB for USC. Two words: Too late.

NL Wild Card: With 10 games to play, the Rockies (who lost last night) are 4 games ahead of both their division rival Giants (who won) and the surprisingly spry Braves. The Rox should know enough about late-season surges to protect themselves against one.

(Will Atlanta put together an inspired streak -- they have already won 3 straight -- in honor of longtime manager Bobby Cox, who announced he will retire after the 2010 season?)

Phillies drama: The biggest difference between this year's team and last year's champs? Not having Lee or Pedro or Happ ... but that last year's lights-out closer, Brad Lidge, is an absolute mess this season -- last night included.

Foreshadowing: The Yankees won their first series in Anaheim since 2004. Picking up on yesterday's lead, I don't think that "home" or "away" will deter the Yankees in the playoffs this season. NBA: Mikhail Prokhorov to buy the Nets -- or, as they quickly became known, the "Nyets." There is Mark Cuban money, and then there is Russian oligarch money. Intriguingly, Prokhorov seems most interested in using the Nets to make Russian basketball better.

Injury Watch: Yup, Yao is still not playing next season.

CBB: Kansas isn't just a leading contender to win a national title; they are scrappy enough to fight with their own football team. Dysfunctional? Sure. But given the success of both teams in 2009 (KU football is unbeaten), that aggression is mostly channeled into winning.

CBB Must-Read: Mike DeCourcy's Top 10 small forwards, led by Ohio State's versatile Evan Turner.

Fun: It turns out that Chad Ochocinco's Lambeau Leap was stacked with sympathetic fans that 85 imported. You are better off assuming that everything in sports is tainted in some way, even the goofy stuff.

One more gripe about the Tebow-Leinart thing: Funny how there's an asterisk next to "two national titles" for Tebow, indicating he wasn't a starter on that 1st title team (although Tebow, as a freshman part-time player, was arguably that team's MVP), but there's no asterisk next to Leinart's "two titles" entry, indicating that USC earned -- at best -- half a national title in 2003 and didn't have to play the next-best team in the country in 2004, unbeaten Auburn. Asterisk that.

The Last Word:"I can't tell you who the best teams in the country are, because frankly I don't get to see them every week. I don't know who's hot and who's not. I could no more rank..." -- LSU coach Les Miles, inadvertently affirming what everyone already knew: That the coaches' poll is a sham.

(At least Miles was being honest -- even if he didn't mean to. Now, let's get an AP voter on the record who is willing to say the same thing: How can they possibly watch enough games intently enough to be able to rank them accurately when they supposedly have their, y'know, full-time job to do on Saturdays?)

Dan Shanoff writes The Wake-Up Call every weekday morning for SportingNews.com and blogs daily at DanShanoff.com. Got any comments, questions or feedback? Email Dan at shanofftsn-[at]-gmail-[dot]-com. Follow him on Twitter at twitter.com/danshanoff.

This post originally appeared on the Sporting Blog. For more, see The Sporting Blog Archives.

Do you like this post?

Comments

Display:

Didn’t you go to Northwestern.  You are just a bandwagon fan anyway.  Get a grip of who vote for best athlete for whatever.  It is all meaningless anyway.  All that matters is how they did on the field and you stated it correctly about Tebow.

by ctfwest on Sep 24, 2009 9:59 AM EDT reply actions  

12 days in a row with mentioning Tebow…this is ridiculous.  The Tebow worship is totally out of hand…and you need to take a step back.  I understand a recap on Monday of the #1 team in the country, or a preview on Friday of the upcoming game, but EVERYDAY is horrible. Get a life!

by thebisondude on Sep 24, 2009 10:14 AM EDT reply actions  

I am a daily reader of the column, as well as the danshanoff.com website (but have never entered, nor do I ever intend to enter, the "teblog"…)(but by the way, thanks for creating a separate site for all things Tebow… now keep them out of the SN column and we’ll be happy!!), and I too must admit that I AM SICK of the Tebow schtick…  for the love of god, please understand that most of your readers are not Florida fans, and you need to appeal to your reader base – stick to what you’re good at, which is giving a brief rundown and instant take on the day’s sports events – THAT’S WHY WE READ, AND YOU DO, THE COLUMN!!!

by showard1986 on Sep 24, 2009 12:48 PM EDT reply actions  

Shanoff also voted Tebow as the athlete of the decade in MLB, the NFL, the NBA, the NHL, the NBDL, the WWE, the UFC, the WNBA, every NCAA athletic pursuit, and wants every Olympic medal ever issued to be taken back and given to Tebow. Then we can rename Christmas and Thanksgiving after Tebow, put him on the front and back of all forms of currency, elect him President, get him knighted in England, replace the Pope with Tebow, and get him taken first overall in the drafts of every professional, organized sport. Furthermore, every award handed out in every sport at every level of organized competition shall be named in Tebow’s honor.

by ChiAdam on Sep 24, 2009 1:49 PM EDT reply actions  

And the Rebel’s ranking was based on handing Tebow his ass.

by ChiAdam on Sep 24, 2009 1:56 PM EDT reply actions  

Give me your best Tebow led Florida Team against Leinart’s led USC team and I’ll take USC all day…..

by SailorGabe on Sep 24, 2009 2:29 PM EDT reply actions  

Agree with showard. I’ve been a regular reader since the ESPN days, but I’m just about done with this column. The Tebow/Florida fellatio just makes getting through the column way too tedious.

by manbags on Sep 24, 2009 3:12 PM EDT reply actions  

Disgaree with me if I am wrong, but after 3 games in 2005 wasn’t Leinart "where his team is not only the favorite to win another national title,
but he is also the leading contender to win another Heisman."

Long season my friend, long season.

by MizzouHoops on Sep 24, 2009 3:22 PM EDT reply actions  

… and also, if there is even a debate on who is the best, doesn’t that shatter your argument that Tebow is easily the greatest of all time?

by MizzouHoops on Sep 24, 2009 4:35 PM EDT reply actions  

Why does everyone give Tebow two national titles? How many snaps did he get in that game? Five? Ten?

Does Colt McCoy have a national title from 2005? Does ANYONE even remember Chris Leak was the quarterback for Florida in 2006?

by r.young on Sep 24, 2009 9:51 PM EDT reply actions  

That’s a good point. Tebow was a gimmick player on that 2005 team. Nothing more. He has progressed (slightly) as a passer since, but he was nowhere near as vital to that team as Leak was.

by ChiAdam on Sep 25, 2009 11:10 AM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed