Player of the Year: Chicago Cubs

Brian Kersey - Getty Images

Usually, the "Player of the Year" label is used for a team's best player. In this series, though, we're trying to spot the single player on each club who best exemplifies his team's 2012 season. For better or worse ...

It's not been a good season for the Chicago Cubs. For all their trials over the years, they hadn't lost 100 games in a season since 1966, before most of their fans were born.

Until this season, that is. Monday night, the Cubs lost their 100th game in 2012 ... and to the Houston Astros, no less.

When the Cubs' new management team -- led by Theo Epstein, of course -- came in last winter, they must have known that 2012 would be a rebuilding year. The club did have one obvious strength, though: a starting rotation that featured Ryan Dempster, Matt Garza, Paul Maholm, and Jeff Samardzija.

Blogger Perspective: Bleed Cubbie Blue

by Al Yellon

When Rob told me he had selected Chris Volstad for his Cubs Player of the Year, I thought... Volstad? Isn't there someone else who exemplifies the Cubs' worst season in 46 years better than a 6-foot-8 sinkerballer?

Someone like Luis Valbuena, a guy who should be a utility infielder on a good team, instead getting 72 starts at the corner Aramis Ramirez used to patrol.

Or Bryan LaHair, who got off to a hot start with an insanely high BABIP -- .600 in 70 April PA in which he hit .390/.471/.780 overall; numbers like that got him an All-Star invitation, which will make him the answer to a trivia question 10 years from now.

But then Volstad went out Tuesday night and had one of his best starts of the year, just the second time he'd gone seven innings in 21 starts, allowing just two runs with no walks and six strikeouts, and lost anyway.

It has to be Volstad. How very Cub.

For more Chicago Cubs coverage, visit Bleed Cubbie Blue.

A lot of teams would have been happy with that quartet, and indeed all four pitched well for the Cubs. But of course there was a problem, in terms of winning games in 2012: the better they pitched, the more the pressure to trade them for prospects. Which is exactly what happened with two of those starters, as Dempster was traded to the Rangers and Maholm to the Braves. Garza might well have been dealt, too, had he not been injured.

Still, you figure with a good front office and just a decent farm system, you can replace the starters you've lost with some guys who are at least decent, right?

The Cubs haven't. Justin Germano started 12 games, and posted a 6.75 ERA. Chris Rusin: 6.37 ERA in seven starts. Brooks Raley: 8.14 ERA in five starts. Jason Berken: winless in four starts, with a 4.82 ERA. The only success story is unimposing Travis Wood, who's gone just 6-13 but has otherwise pitched decently in his 25 starts.

Unfortunately, Wood's solid work has been balanced by Chris Volstad's performance. Volstad seemed to be exactly the sort of pitcher who could help a team like the Cubs. His career ERA seemed somewhat deceptive, perhaps masking his true talents. And he was still young by the pitching standards, only 25. Maybe he could, with a little luck and a bit of natural maturation, establish himself as a part of the Cubs' future, rather than just the disappointing present.

Instead -- and even with a solid outing against the Astros, Tuesday night -- Volstad finished the campaign with only three wins (and a dozen losses) in 21 starts. Oh, and a 6.31 ERA, the second highest in franchise history among Cubs with at least 20 starts.

A few things went well for the Cubs this season. Anthony Rizzo proved he's a major leaguer, and Samardzija developed nicely. But the Cubs lost 100 games largely because management couldn't find a few starting pitchers who could pitch just decently for two or three months.

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.


You must be a member of to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at You should read them.


You must be a member of to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.