Post Combine Consensus

Consensus decision-making is a group decision making process that seeks the consent, not necessarily the agreement, of participants and the resolution of objections. Consensus is defined by Merriam-Webster as, first, general agreement, and second, group solidarity of belief or sentiment. It has its origin in a Latin word meaning literally feel together.[1] It is used to describe both the decision and the process of reaching a decision. Consensus decision-making is thus concerned with the process of reaching a consensus decision, and the social and political effects of using this process.

From Wiki

A pipe dream I know, we can't even agree after the players are selected in the Draft :)

I am trying again to create a consensus Player big board by combining the top-100 players lists from,, and

An asterisk indicates a tie in scoring the three player lists. A (2) indicates a player only appeared on two lists.

Site nationalfootballpost cbssports mockingthedraft Brandt Combine Consensus
1. Andrew Luck Andrew Luck Andrew Luck Luck 97.0 Andrew Luck
2. Morris Claiborne Robert Griffin III Matt Kalil Griffin 91.5 Morris Claiborne
3. David DeCastro Matt Kalil Trent Richardson Kalil 94.0 Matt Kalil
4. Trent Richardson Morris Claiborne Morris Claiborne Coples - Trent Richardson
5. Michael Brockers Justin Blackmon Robert Griffin III Claiborne 95.0 Robert Griffin III
6. Matt Kalil Trent Richardson Justin Blackmon Richardson 93.5 Justin Blackmon
7. Robert Griffin III Riley Reiff Dre Kirkpatrick Tannehill 92.5 David DeCastro
8. Luke Kuechly Quinton Coples Courtney Upshaw Reiff 92.0 Quinton Coples
9. Quinton Coples Melvin Ingram David DeCastro Kirkpatrick 90.0 Michael Brockers
10. Justin Blackmon Michael Brockers Jonathan Martin Ingram 91.0 Luke Kuechly
11. Melvin Ingram Ryan Tannehill Quinton Coples Kuechly 92.0 Dre Kirkpatrick
12. Cordy Glenn David DeCastro Devon Still Blackmon 90.5 Melvin Ingram
13. Orson Charles Michael Floyd Riley Reiff Poe 89.5 Michael Floyd
14. Kendall Wright Luke Kuechly Luke Kuechly DeCastro 89.0 Devon Still
15. Mark Barron Janoris Jenkins Michael Brockers Jenkins 86.0 Riley Reiff
16. Fletcher Cox Jonathan Martin Dont'a Hightower Floyd 88.5 Kendall Wright
17. Dre Kirkpatrick Devon Still Michael Floyd Upshaw 88.0 Courtney Upshaw
18. Peter Konz Dre Kirkpatrick Whitney Mercilus Brown 91.5 Janoris Jenkins
19. Mike Adams Kendall Wright Peter Konz Still 85.0 Peter Konz
20. Michael Floyd Fletcher Cox Kendall Wright J. Martin 72.5 Cordy Glenn
21. Janoris Jenkins Courtney Upshaw Janoris Jenkins Brockers 85.0 Dont'a Hightower *
22. Devon Still Dontari Poe Zach Brown Randle 84.0 Ryan Tannehill *
23. Coby Fleener Cordy Glenn Brandon Thompson Glenn 91.7 Mark Barron
24. Brandon Thompson Rueben Randle Andre Branch Perry 54.0 Mike Adams
25. Courtney Upshaw Nick Perry David Wilson Cox 77.0 Fletcher Cox *
26. Alameda Ta'amu Whitney Mercilus Melvin Ingram Barron 87.0 Jonathan Martin *
27. Dont'a Hightower Jerel Worthy Stephon Gilmore Wright 74.0 Stephen Hill (2)
28. Stephen Hill Peter Konz Ryan Tannehill Osemele 89.0 Dontari Poe *
29. Stephon Gilmore Dont'a Hightower Lamar Miller Mercilus 84.5 Brandon Thompson *
30. Nick Perry Kendall Reyes Dwayne Allen Worthy 84.0 Stephon Gilmore **
31. David Wilson Mark Barron Alshon Jeffery Burfict 87.5 Nick Perry **
32. Riley Reiff Stephen Hill Chris Polk Hill 86.5 David Wilson
33. Ryan Tannehill Mike Adams Mike Adams Reyes 87.0 Dwayne Allen
34. Dontari Poe Zach Brown Mohamed Sanu Wilson 87.0 Lamar Miller *
35. Amini Silatolu Andre Branch Dontari Poe Allen 72.5 Whitney Mercilus *
36. Brandon Washington Dwayne Allen Cordy Glenn Miller 79.0 Orson Charles
37. Lavonte David Alfonzo Dennard Lavonte David Hightower 87.7 Lavonte David
38. Lamar Miller Kelechi Osemele Vinny Curry Branch 91.0 Zach Brown
39. Brandon Boykin Stephon Gilmore Mark Barron Boykin 85.2 Coby Fleener
40. Jared Crick David Wilson Orson Charles Thompson 79.0 Andre Branch
41. Ben Jones Kevin Zeitler Dwight Jones Curry 79.5 Jerel Worthy
42. Dwayne Allen Lamar Miller Jerel Worthy Hosley 85.2 Kelechi Osemele
43. Mohamed Sanu Brock Osweiler Kelechi Osemele Charles 89.7 Jared Crick
44. Brandon Brooks Brandon Thompson Chandler Jones Fleming 84.0 Mohamed Sanu
45. Markelle Martin Lavonte David Vontaze Burfict Givens 84.7 Amini Silatolu
46. Jamell Fleming Alshon Jeffery Brandon Weeden Fleener 85.7 Alfonzo Dennard
47. Andrew Datko Bobby Wagner Jared Crick Konz 53.2 Alameda Ta'amu
48. Chase Minnifield Doug Martin Alameda Ta'amu Adams 83.5 Brock Osweiler (2) *
49. Doug Martin Chris Givens Jamell Fleming Minnifield 73.0 Chandler Jones (2) *
50. Josh Norman Zebrie Sanders Coby Fleener Dennard 74.2 Doug Martin
51. Cam Johnson Coby Fleener Fletcher Cox Irvin 58.5 Shea McClellin (2)
52. Casey Hayward Trumaine Johnson Brandon Washington Zeitler 85.0 Zebrie Sanders (2)
53. Shea McClellin Brandon Weeden Travis Lewis McClellin 76.0 Brandon Boykin
54. Bruce Irvin Jared Crick Chase Minniefield Winn 79.5 Kevin Zeitler *
55. Alfonzo Dennard Shea McClellin Markelle Martin Sanu 82.0 Brandon Weeden *
56. Jarius Wright Brandon Boykin Kevin Zeitler Weeden - Bobby Wagner
57. Joe Adams Ronnell Lewis Bernard Pierce Crick 82.0 Alshon Jeffery
58. Kelechi Osemele Orson Charles Alfonzo Dennard David 86.0 Bruce Irvin (2)
59. Ronnell Lewis Vinny Curry Zebrie Sanders Gilmore 66.2 Ben Jones
60. Jerel Worthy Chandler Jones Nick Perry Sanders 68.7 Travis Lewis (2)
61. Jonathan Martin Sean Spence Brock Osweiler Chapman 56.2 Markelle Martin
62. Trumaine Johnson Dwight Bentley Doug Martin James 56.5 Kendall Reyes
63. Coryell Judie Bruce Irvin Josh Chapman Osweiler - Brandon Brooks (2) *
64. Zach Brown Amini Silatolu Bobby Wagner Iloka 68.2 Cam Johnson (2) *
65. Whitney Mercilus Ben Jones Josh Norman AJ Jenkins 83.5 Trumaine Johnson
66. Josh Chapman Billy Winn Harrison Smith Hayward 81.5 Chase Minniefield
67. Mitchell Schwartz Isaiah Pead Nick Toon R. Lewis 83.7 Josh Chapman (2)
68. Andre Branch George Iloka Kendall Reyes D. Martin 83.0 Rueben Randle
69. Travis Lewis Mohamed Sanu Leonard Johnson Ma. Martin 66.0 Ronnell Lewis
70. Marvin Jones Jayron Hosley Ladarius Green Washington 79.5 Vinny Curry
71. Bobby Wagner Harrison Smith Brandon Boykin Criner 69.7 Dwight Jones
72. Brandon Weeden Nick Toon James-Michael Johnson Crawford 80.2 Sean Spence (2)
73. Jeff Allen LaMichael James Robert Turbin Gray 84.5 Harrison Smith
74. Kevin Zeitler Bobby Massie Michael Egnew Jeffery 73.7 Casey Hayward (2) *
75. Demario Davis Cam Johnson Ben Jones M. Martin 58.0 Mitchell Schwartz (2) *
76. Lucas Nix Mike Martin Jonathan Masaquoi T. Johnson 83.5 Jamell Fleming
77. Harrison Smith Mitchell Schwartz Trumaine Johnson C. Jones 86.0 Chris Polk
78. Tony Bergstrom Alameda Ta'amu Mike Martin H. Smith 72.2 Leonard Johnson (2)
79. Robert Turbin Leonard Johnson Marvin McNutt Spence 84.0 Billy Winn (2)
80. Rueben Randle Josh Kaddu Nick Foles J. Adams 83.0 Nick Toon
81. Sean Spence Kirk Cousins Ronnell Lewis B. Polk 74.5 Robert Turbin (2)
82. Malik Jackson Nigel Bradham Brandon Brooks Polk 66.7 Josh Norman
83. Tyrone Crawford James Brown Joe Adams Silatolu 51.2 Demario Davis (2) *
84. DaJohn Harris Matt McCants Billy Winn Robinson 84.7 Vontaze Burfict (2) *
85. Christian Thompson Brandon Washington Michael Brewster J. Brown 73.0 George Iloka
86. Matt McCants Demario Davis Mychal Kendricks Cousins 66.7 James-Michael Johnson (2)
87. Nick Toon Chris Polk Jayron Hosley Datko 89.5 Chris Givens (2)
88. Audie Cole Markelle Martin George Iloka Ta'amu 59.7 Mike Martin
89. George Iloka Senio Kelemete Brian Quick Pierce 56.0 Ladarius Green (2)
90. Brandon Mosley Chase Minnifield Audie Cole Massie 57.0 Bernard Pierce
91. Kendall Reyes Mychal Kendricks Dominique Hamilton Bradham 56.0 Matt McCants
92. James-Michael Johnson Casey Hayward Rueben Randle Wagner 67.5 Audie Cole (2)
93. Evan Rodriguez Juron Criner Levy Adcock K. Robinson 56.0 Kirk Cousins (2)
94. Mychal Kendricks Josh Robinson LaMichael James Wade 79.7 Mychal Kendricks
95. Brandon Taylor Dwight Jones Terrell Manning Bentley 86.0 Jayron Hosley
96. Alshon Jeffery Bernard Pierce Matt McCants Stephenson 52.0 Marvin McNutt (2)
97. Mike Martin Kheeston Randall Jeff Fuller LeRibeus 74.5 Lucas Nix (2) *
98. Keenan Robinson Ladarius Green Kirk Cousins Mosley 84.7 Brian Quick (2) *
99. Kelcie McCray Cyrus Gray Keenan Robinson T. Robinson 51.2 Tony Bergstrom (2) *
100. Bernard Pierce Brian Quick Ryan Broyles Anger 78.5 LaMichael James

Combine Scores Here, scores are those of the player to the Right. I found Gil Brandt's Top 100 after the combine and included it for further reference. It is not included in the consensus score.

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.


You must be a member of to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at You should read them.


You must be a member of to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.