World Series of the Week: Royals vs. Tigers


by Steven Goldman The Royals last posted a full-season winning record 10 years ago. After a winter in which general manager Dayton Moore gave up waiting for homegrown pitching to catch up to his cadre of young position players and imported a professional rotation, the Royals are indeed pitching better. Even though the hitters have thus far been disappointing, the team is currently 10-7 and the owners of a one-game lead in the AL Central.

So is it all over now? Can we look at the Royals like we did the Rays after 2008 and assume they are finally off a road to recovery that began (more or less) in the 1980s? Not so fast. While the team’s current record is a welcome change from last year’s 3-14 at the same point, the team has been here before: they started 9-8 in both 2008 and 2009 and 11-6 in 2011.

In the latter year they made it all the way through April before the wheels came off, but from then until September they went 42-68. A 15-10 final month finished the season with a touch of dignity, but that neither salvaged a season in which they finished 71-91 nor served as a predictor of better results the next year. In short, this seems like a new-look Royals team now, but we might start to recognize them as spring turns to summer.

Handicapped by poor management and an owner who runs the team as if you got prizes for parsimony, the Royals now are in the grip of something much more difficult to overcome: the widely varying results of their efforts to build through the farm. Billy Butler. the team’s first-round pick in 2004, reached the majors in 2007, and took two years to turn into a top-quality hitter. Alex Gordon, drafted the next year and promoted in 2007, seemed like a huge bust after four seasons in the majors, but broke through in 2011 and since has been a strong hitter and a Gold-Glove defender besides.

The pitchers that were supposed to accompany them simply didn’t show up. Meanwhile, the second wave of sluggers has foundered. The Royals are now in year three of subsequent first-rounders Mike Moustakas (2007) and Eric Hosmer (2008), and to invoke the Thunderclap Newman hit climbing the charts when the Royals came into being, they have got to get it together now because Ervin Santana is a free agent following this season, James Shields’ contract is up after 2014, and Butler’s is done after 2015. Other prospects are on the way, of course, but the Royals revival is precariously balanced.
As for the Tigers, the defending American League pennant winners remain a fascinating contrast in conflicting imperatives, starting with one of the game’s best pitching staffs supported (if that is the right word) by one of its worst defenses. Entering Sunday they were tied for last in the majors in defensive efficiency (the park-adjusted version of the stat has them decisively last), the ability of a team to convert balls in play into outs.

The AL Central’s presumptive favorites probably didn’t expect to find themselves fighting it out with the Royals for the division lead at this or any point of the season, and it will be fascinating to watch how they choose to upgrade the club if it again finds itself in a tight race. Last year, Dave Dombrowski added second baseman Omar Infante at the trading deadline. This year, it might be the club’s lack of a big-name closer that will get most of the media attention, but helping the pitching staff retire batters by something other than strikeouts will again be the crying need.

Players to watch

by Steven Goldman

Max Scherzer

Right-handed pitcher

Not just on the cusp of something good, but already there. Shellacked a few times last April, his ERA from May on was 3.14, with 204 strikeouts in 163.1 innings (11.2 per nine) -- right-handed batters hit only .168/.202/.304 during that span. This year, Scherzer was once again a bit off in his initial outing but has dominated since then, with 23 strikeouts and two earned runs in 14 innings. With the exception of Alex Gordon, Royals left-handed hitters haven’t done much this year, so unless Scherzer has one of his increasingly infrequent off days, Game 1 could be over mercifully fast.

Austin Jackson


To date, the WAR score on the three-way trade that brought Jackson and Scherzer to Detroit is Tigers 26.2, Yankees 12.9, Diamondbacks 9.9. That’s only going to slant more in the Tigers’ direction as Jackson continues to mature into one of the game’s best two-way players. He’s been a far better hitter at Comerica than elsewhere; somehow his line drives find gaps there they don’t on the road. That’s going to change one day soon and Miguel Cabrera won’t be the only Tigers position player with an MVP award.

Torii Hunter

Old Guy

Now over 2,000 hits, which is impressive given that for all Hunter’s long-lived excellence, he was a late bloomer -- drafted just before his 18th birthday, it took six years for him to become a big-league regular, eight for him to be even average with the bat, and nine for him have his first truly strong offensive season. Hunter was a highlight-reel defender in his 20s, but he’s been a much better hitter in his 30s (.267/.321/.458 through age-29, .287/.349/.474 in tougher offensive conditions since). A team takes a chance anytime it signs an older player coming off of a career-best season, but if any player is going to thwart pessimistic expectations, it would be Hunter.

James Shields

Right-handed pitcher

Moore’s folly may lie in prematurely raising Shields, which, as any "Star Trek" aficionado will tell you, can really put a crimp in your long-term outlook. Shields would be an asset to any team, but as a pricey veteran who has one year (a team option) remaining on his contract, spending a top prospect to get him made sense only if he would make a decisive difference this year or the next. What seems more likely is that Shields will finish his contract and depart, while Wil Myers will be playing for the Rays for the next 3-6 years. Hey, Royals fans, at least he’s more fun to watch than Jonathan Sanchez.

Alex Gordon

Former bust

A third baseman who neither hits nor fields is moved to left field and becomes a Gold Glove-winning leadoff man? Go figure. Gordon is the exception to many rules: most busted prospects stay busted rather than turn into all-around threats. Now there’s a little hope for the hopeless, a category that normally includes the Royals and may yet include Alphonse Hosmer and Gaston Moustakas. Gordon and Butler are both doubles machines -- so why does Ned Yost fill the need to put Alcides Escobar between them like an offensive chastity belt?

Eric Hosmer

Near bust

Currently hitting .261/.346/.283, bringing to mind Casey Stengel’s line about Frank Howard: "How can a guy who's so big and strong hit the ball so near?" A: By making weak contact. Last season, Hosmer’s 14-percent line drive rate was tied for last among qualified major leaguers. During the offseason, the Royals fired their hitting coach and Yost boasted that they would become a power team by being more aggressive. Despite hitting four home runs in Sunday’s doubleheader sweep, they only have 10 home runs on the season. Wishing doesn’t make it so, especially when you have an enigma like Hosmer, who has a very pretty swing and very ugly results.

About the park

by Steven Goldman

Comerica Park: Formerly an extreme pitcher’s park, Comerica has played fair on both sides of the ball since the left field fence was dragged in prior to the 2003 season. It’s still a bit hard on the home run hitters, but with an expansive center field (at 420 feet one of the deepest in the majors), a fast player who hits one in the gaps has a good chance of making it to third. Since the reconfiguration, the Tigers have hit the most triples in the American League, and trail the Rockies for the major-league lead over that period 419-413.

The vast foul territory leads to far more foul outs than in most ballparks (and also puts fans in the field level seats about six miles from the action). Justin Verlander has been very hard to beat here, with a 3.01 ERA (versus 3.74 on the road) and a .717 winning percentage. In fact, the Tigers have been very tough here overall: Over the last five years, hitters have averaged .282/.348/.450 at Comerica versus just .257/.325/.402 on the road. Since going 40-41 at home in 2008, the Tigers have had a .627 winning percentage at home, tantamount to going 101-62 over a full season.

In a city that longs for renewal Comerica Park is a place in the heart of downtown that is fully renewed. Opened in 2000, Comerica exhibits all of the features fans expect from a modern park: wide concourses, unencumbered sight lines, plenty of concessions, luxury suites, and great views of the cityscape. Some baseball folk at first scoffed at the childish Ferris wheel and carousel, but these features seem downright quaint 13 years later as other parks have added fish tanks, pools, "home run features," and mascots sliding into barrels of beer.

While fans are still haunted by the warm memories of haloed Tiger Stadium, they respect the care that was taken to endow the new park with gravitas and history. As an homage to Tiger Stadium the field is one of the most spacious in baseball. The architecture is neo-classic with latticed iron light stanchions and sweeping brick walls. Just beyond the outfield wall stand statues of Tigers greats such as Ty Cobb -- sliding hard, spikes up.

Comerica is simply a great place to take in a game and enjoy a Michigan craft brew, Little Ceasar's pizza, or maybe even a hot dog delivered by Charlie the Signing Hot Dog Man himself. Perhaps in the process you'll find a little renewal for yourself too. /end "Pure Michigan" commercial
- Eric Wayne, AKA @PhilCokesBrain

JUST Ask the locals!

from Bless You Boys and Royals Review

Catch a Tiger?

"Years ago, picking the Tigers and Royals to be the World Series of the Week would have been like some cruel joke school kids play on each other, like a contest to see who can bring the biggest loser to the dance. But in the movies and TV shows, the loser goes through a magical montage: their hair is styled, their clothes selected from the hottest designers, and all attention turns their way when they step into the hall.

Seven seasons back, the Tigers went through that transition to go from loser to homecoming king: Today, they have several of the game's top stars, a fearsome lineup and one of the best rotations in baseball. They're baseball's success story.

Coming off their ninth season below .500, the Royals have yet to complete their metamorphosis, but there's no denying that Kansas City has its best team in years. The Royals probably won't be in the division hunt at the end of September, but this series is a great chance to see where they stand today." - Kurt Mensching, Bless You Boys

It's possible!

"The moves the Royals made this winter attempting to upgrade their rotation were made with the Detroit Tigers in mind. Because, who else?

The Tigers are the cream of a mediocre Central crop, so if Dayton Moore and the Royals braintrust has designs on contention, they’re correct to target the Tigers as Public Enemy Number One. Their most memorable recent regular season series came at the end of 2006. With the Tigers and Twins tied for first place the Royals went to Detroit and won all three games, costing the Tigers the chance for the division title. My friend who is a Tigers fan is still bitter. Great.

For Royals fans, that series meant we passed Tampa in the race for the worst record in baseball. The following year, the Rays selected David Price as the number one overall pick in the draft. Really, who won? Besides the Rays?

Today the Royals don’t have rivals as much as they have opponents who annoy. Twins fans form an invading mob, taking over Kauffman Stadium. The Indians beat us in cruel fashion and remind us we haven’t won in forever. The White Sox are the White Sox. The Tigers? There simply isn’t much of a rivalry there. Maybe this is the year it changes." - Craig Brown, Royals Review

One Key Stat: .167/.273/.182

by Steven Goldman

With Victor Martinez missing the 2012 season due to surgery on his left knee, designated hitter was a major disappointment for the Tigers last year. Delmon Young got the majority of the plate appearances and hit a miserable .260/.287/.388. V-Mart, a career .303/.370/.469 hitter coming into the season, has returned, but the hits have been few and far between. It’s tough to come back from a whole year away, especially at 34. If the Tigers are going to justify the defensive hit they take by putting Prince Fielder and Miguel Cabrera in the field, they need the designated hitter to produce at a high level. That hasn’t been the case for a while. P.S.: Martinez is making $13 million this year and is under contract for next year at $12 million.

Bottom Line: Tigers tag the Royals, 2-1

by Steven Goldman Detroit comes into this series cold, having been swept by the Angels, but Scherzer and Verlander give the Tigers a pair of aces in the first two games that will be tough for the Royals to beat. The Tigers' struggling bats will be quieted just enough by Shields in Game 3 that the Royals sneak out a win against the very difficult Anibal Sanchez and stave off a sweep.
Please post your predictions below.

Game 1: Results pending

Postponed! Makeup date TBA. Game 1 starters pushed back to Game 2.

Game 2: Tigers 7, Royals 5

Just like old times: Jose Valverde returns and saves the game.Bless You Boys recap: The Tigers' bullpen pitched four scoreless innings, topped by the return of Jose Valverde, who nailed down the save.

Royals Review recap
: Not the finest effort from a Royals starter this season.

Game 3: Royals 8, Tigers 3

Justin Verlander pitched well, but the bullpen was a letdown.

Bless You Boys recap: As bad as the Tigers' bullpen looked, their offense was worse in a 10-inning loss to the Royals.

Royals Review recap: The Royals won the BIG GAME. George Kottaras took a walk with the bases loaded to give the Royals the lead in the 10th. Then Alex Gordon put the game away with a Grand Slam.

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.


You must be a member of to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at You should read them.


You must be a member of to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.