MLB's first quarter report card: Best, worst, and in-between


The surprises, the expected, and a little bit of everything else from the first quarter of the 2013 season.

Due to rampant rainouts and the vagaries of the schedule, teams have played an uneven number of games, but as of Wednesday night, 19 teams had played between 40 and 42 games. One-quarter of the season is now in the books. While there are no official awards for player or team of the quarter, there are several obvious possibilities that we will happily deputize ourselves to award.

Biggest Positive Surprise of the Quarter, Player

I hate to go all Brewers on you here, but Carlos Gomez and Jean Segura have to take the price. Gomez is such a good athlete that he made it to the majors at 21 and stayed up despite hitting just .243/.291/.357 in his first five seasons. Power arrived in 2011, his ISO (slugging percentage minus batting average) jumping from his career .102 to .177, then stepping up again to .202 last year. On-base percentage was still a problem, but when you play a rangy center field and run the bases at light speed, the overall package makes up for any one deficiency. This year, though, none of that applies -- Gomez is leading the National League in batting average and has already hit six home runs, leading to .365/.404/.620 rates.

Join our Brewers community, Brew Crew Ball

Segura, a seemingly nondescript piece of the Zack Greinke trade, has come on like a late-‘90s Derek Jeter on vitamins (not steroids, because we all know that Jeter never does anything wrong), hitting .349/.392/.575 with seven home runs and leading the NL in stolen bases with 13 swipes in 15 tries. Segura was a .313 hitter in the minors, so his hitting for average isn't a complete surprise, but he homered once every 60 at-bats -- by that standard he should have about three home runs now.

Josh Donaldson of the A's doesn't come as a total surprise -- he hit .290/.356/.489 and played excellent defense after taking over third base from Brandon Inge last August, but at .316/.390/.520 he's showing that he gave an honest accounting of himself. Other possibilities: Vernon Wells of the Yankees, James Loney (a league-leading .379 average for the Rays).

Biggest Positive Surprise of the Quarter, Pitcher

No doubt some would take Matt Harvey or Clay Buchholz here, but Harvey has all the talent in the world and Buchholz has been pitching well since last May, albeit not this well. The same might apply to Seattle's Hisashi Iwakuma, who had a 2.65 ERA in 16 starts last year. He's definitely taken a step forward, cutting his walk rate by more than half, but his success still shouldn't come as a total surprise. The same can't be said of Travis Wood of the Cubs, who has a 2.03 ERA in eight starts -- his career mark entering the season was 4.22. He seemed like just another fifth starter on a second-division club, but he's had good luck on balls in play this year -- the .196 BABIP against him is the second-lowest on the circuit. He's wedged between Matt Harvey and fellow Cub Scott Feldman, another guy whose results come as something of a shock.

Let's throw an honorable mention Ervin Santana's way -- the Royals righty always seems to swing between good and evil versions of himself, like the Batman villain Two-Face. This year, the coin-flip came up good, and Santana has cut his walk rate to 1.1 per nine and his home run-rate roughly in half.

Biggest Disappointment of the Quarter, Player

There are many veteran possibilities here. Jeff Keppinger has been the worst player in baseball by at least one measure, but last season's .325 average was something of a fluke, and Keppinger's skill set is such that if he's not hitting .300 he's not helping you. Victor Martinez has been terrible, but the guy is 34 and missed a year, so what do you want? Adam Dunn has been a mess, at least until the last two games, but he was here in 2011 as well, so we can't exactly claim to be surprised. As such, I'm going to go with Atlanta's B.J. Upton (.145/.242/.244, not getting better) and Josh Hamilton (.214/.264/.358 and battling illness).

Biggest Disappointment of the Quarter, Pitcher

Giants starter Ryan Vogelsong's major-league comeback after five years away from the majors was a great story in 2011. It still is and always will be, but it might now be a case of, "We'll always have Paris": Vogelsong's eight starts have resulted in an 8.06 ERA and a league-worst 11 home runs. Here's hoping he has another rabbit under his cap.

Best Results, Offseason Acquisition

Shin-Soo Choo has quietly been an excellent player for years. He's outdone himself so far this year with the Reds, hitting .322/.465/.589 with nine home runs. His OBP leads the NL, and oddly enough Dusty Baker bats him leadoff. Call this a tie with Justin Upton, who leads the NL with 13 home runs. He's been pretty quiet in May, perhaps because teams are starting to pitch around him. Granted, that beats at him: Choo has been hit by a pitch a league-leading dozen times.

Photo credit: Andy Lyons

Worst Results, Offseason Acquisition

Let's call it Keppinger, hitting .185/.182/.207 with no walks through 137 plate appearances.

Living Up to the Hype

Manny Machado, Baltimore Orioles; Bryce Harper, Washington Nationals.

Not Living Up to the Hype

Aaron Hicks, Minnesota Twins; Lonnie Chisenhall, Cleveland Indians; Eric Hosmer and Mike Moustakas, Kansas City Royals.

Real, Not Faking It

The Orioles seemed to be in line for some major regression after last season's surprise run, but so far they've defied the laws of entropy.

Faking It, Not Real

The Kansas City Royals have a +17 run differential. Given the third-worst aggregate infield production in the league, they might not be able to keep that up, especially if Lorenzo Cain regresses and their outfield production starts to drop off.

Can We Go On Like This?

KC's Jeff Francoeur, following up a .235/.287/.378 season with a .221/.258/.311 start, and Milwaukee's Rickie Weeks, hitting .187/.306/.299 after hitting .230/.328/.400 in 2012.

Photo credit: USA TODAY Sports

Good Player/Bad Team

Jose Altuve (.333/.371/.444).

Bad Player/Good Team

Eduardo Nunez, New York Yankees. When Jayson Nix looks like the better alternative, you know there's a problem.

Free This Player!

Giancarlo Stanton, healthy or injured.


Padres outfielder Will Venable is an excellent defender who is hitting .250/.330/.450 due to unusually robust hitting at home. He's a career .270/.338/.444 hitter away from Petco, so this is what he's capable of doing in a fair park. His road stats are uncharacteristically flat, so if he can maintain his hot hand at home (perhaps the new dimensions have given him a boost) and get back to his normal production elsewhere, he's going to have a breakout year at 30.

Consistently Frustrating Batting Order

In the NL, Dusty Baker has batted Zack Cozart second in 28 of his 36 games despite his hitting .214/.242/.352 this year and .246/.288/.399 last year. In the AL, Terry Francona has kept Carlos Santana in the fifth or sixth spots (for eight and 20 games, respectively) despite his .430 OBP (following up on his very respectful .365 last season), while Jason Kipnis and Asdrubal Cabrera have been locked in the second and third slots.

Comeback Kid

Mark Melancon, Pittsburgh Pirates.

Anyone Can Close

Jason Grilli, Pittsburgh Pirates; Kevin Gregg, Chicago Cubs.

Well, Maybe Not Everyone

Carlos Marmol, Chicago Cubs.

Over or Just Cold?

Ichiro Suzuki, New York Yankees; Paul Konerko, Chicago White Sox.


St. Louis Cardinals if they keep up their great starting pitching, Miami Marlins if they continue to excel at not hitting.

More from SB Nation:

Clayton Kershaw, historically relevant ace

Bartolo Colon's surprising career first

8 scouting reports that nailed it

When keeping bat flips real goes wrong

How do players do on their bobblehead nights?

The "luckiest" and "unluckiest" hitters of 2013

In This Article

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior users will need to choose a permanent username, along with a new password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

I already have a Vox Media account!

Verify Vox Media account

Please login to your Vox Media account. This account will be linked to your previously existing Eater account.

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior MT authors will need to choose a new username and password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.


You must be a member of to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at You should read them.


You must be a member of to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.