I'm not sure if there is a clickier possible headline. Let's try:
Yasiel Puig hits Kate Upton with throw, Mike Trout out
The story of Yasiel Puig's throw to nab Mike Trout, as told through otter GIFs
What is your Yasiel Puig/Mike Trout name? Enter your name into our Yasiel Puig/Mike Trout name generator to find out!
Perhaps. But if you're looking for a baseball-related headline for a baseball-related event, that's as close as you're going to get to maximum Internet interest.
Good thing the video delivers. Baseball!