Nov 8, 2010 - Some thoughts on Sunday's eventful NASCAR race at Texas Motor Speedway...
I'm glad Jeff Gordon and Jeff Burton threw down during Sunday's race and had a fight. I don't care who the drivers were or what the circumstances were - NASCAR needs that kind of publicity and highlight-reel moment to break through the crowded sports media landscape today. How many more people paid attention to horse racing's Breeders' Cup this weekend (or realized it was even taking place) as a result of Friday's fight between jockeys? Same concept applies to NASCAR.
It doesn't minimize the on-track competition to get excited about a fight; it just enhances the overall product, which is built both on selling personalities and entertaining racing. A fight wasn't the main headline from yesterday's race, it was just one of them. In an era when all the drivers live together in a motorhome lot and talk things out behind the scenes to diffuse potential rivalries, physical confrontations have been far too rare.
On the scale of sportsmanship, though, a fight between competitors is different than gesturing toward a NASCAR official. Fighting in sports is often about defending honor (hockey "enforcers," baseball pitchers following the "code" of retaliation); flipping off the ref is never a good idea in any form of competition.
Kyle Busch's middle finger toward a NASCAR official was not an act of "passion." It was the act of a poor sport. I'm tired of people offering excuses for Busch when he acts like a brat whose parents never told him, "HEY! You can't behave like that, son!"
There's a huge difference between wanting to win very badly (as Busch so obviously does) and throwing temper tantrums when you lose. Busch can still figure out a way to express how much he hates losing – and maintain that passion his fans love so much – without having the kind of meltdowns most people grow out of after high school.
That said, NASCAR absolutely should not issue any further penalties to Busch. It already penalized him on the track for two laps; typically, if such actions are taken during the race, NASCAR says "We're done with it" and moves on. However, it wouldn't surprise me if, given Busch's angry reaction after the Nationwide race on Saturday and his continued attempts to "stand up them" (in Busch's words), the sanctioning body tries to send a message with an additional fine or penalty.
As for the fight? NASCAR absolutely cannot penalize Gordon or Burton. It would be completely hypocritical to say, "Have at it, boys!" and then say, "Ha! We caught you! Now pay $25,000." If anything, NASCAR should send Gordon a bottle of wine as a thank-you gesture for the publicity.
Too often, we fall into the trap of trying to apply examples of things that happen in NASCAR to our normal lives. It's similar to saying of the Busch situation, "Well, I flip off cops on the freeway, I just don't have an in-car camera." Yes, but you also don't get paid millions of dollars and participate in a professional sport.
Being a pro athlete comes with an expectation of acting like a professional – and that's why I think Jimmie Johnson's pit crew swap won't be a huge issue for that team.
If my boss replaced me with someone else because I couldn't get the job done, I'd be furious. I might want to walk off the job. My feelings would be bruised, as would my pride. But while some of the 48 team's crew members may have felt that way initially, I fully expect the team will show up at Phoenix – if asked – and do a professional job in putting their feelings aside.
At first, I thought Chad Knaus was making a huge mistake. I reasoned: He just completely destroyed their confidence and told them they couldn't get the job done. They're ruined. But if you think about it, there's potential for the move to make the 48 crew work even harder. And that will likely have to happen for Johnson to win another championship, because my gut feeling is Rick Hendrick won't let Knaus have the 24 team's pit crew for the remainder of the season (Hendrick would view that as unfair to Gordon and his sponsors).
Still, I don't agree with Knaus making the swap in the middle of the race. It seems uncharacteristic of the 48 team to pull a "desperation move," as Denny Hamlin's crew chief Mike Ford was happy to point out. If Johnson loses the championship, those who document the sport will look back and point to Texas as a key swing in momentum.
Speaking of crew chief Ford, the man had a lot to say in his post-race comments, mainly puffing his chest and declaring that his team was better than Johnson's. He also made the "desperation move" comment and said he was immune to any mind games the 48 team might play and took some shots at the competition.
That may all be true, but smack talk seems to backfire in sports so often – bulletin board material and all that – you can't help but wonder if Ford would be wiser to keep his swagger and attitude toward the four-time consecutive champions to himself and his team. At least until he's holding the trophy at Homestead.
As for the trophy, though it's feeling more and more like Hamlin's year – and less like one of those typical Johnson Cup runs – I'm still sticking with the 48 as my championship pick. Until he proves otherwise, Johnson is the man to beat. Hamlin, though, just might be the guy who ends Johnson's reign.
Comments
I don’t agree with the 48/24 pit crew swap at all. Why? Because I’m a Junior fan. Sometimes I think Hendrick’s decision on how to run his team comes from a magic 8 ball.
by jr88freak on Nov 8, 2010 10:23 AM EST reply actions
What does the 88 have to do with a pit crew swap between the 48/24?
by karen s on Nov 8, 2010 10:27 AM EST up reply actions
What? Because we’ve been waiting for something to change on the 88 team and so far nothing has happened and they’ve performed worse than the 48 and 24. But in the middle of the race, the 48 gjuys have a couple bad pit stops and all of a sudden those guys ain’t good enough for the 48 they nab the 24 team. Changes made for the golden boy at HMS. A few bad pit stops mean a crew change for the 48 but 2 bad years for the 88 means nothing. Nada. Zip.
by jr88freak on Nov 8, 2010 11:41 AM EST up reply actions
88 isn't running for a championship
That’s the reason why the change yesterday, JJ was #1 in points for the championship.
The pit crew swap has nothing to do with the 88.
by karen s on Nov 8, 2010 12:45 PM EST up reply actions
Fords's comments weren't classy
Don’t get me wrong, I like Denny and think this could be his year but after Ford’s comments I just kinda want the 48 to win next week and Denny to blow an engine.
Gordon’s passion and fighting was great for the sport, it made me sit up and notice. It made people talk about the race again. “Did you see Gordon throw down…” were a lot of comments. The fans in stands were loving it and cheering it on. It’s what Nascar needs, more passion.
NONE of them plus Kyle should be punished further.
by karen s on Nov 8, 2010 10:29 AM EST reply actions
Yesterday's race
was definitely intense. I had several friends that I didn’t even know watched the races comment on my page after I said something about the Gordon/Burton fight. It seemed to be all people could talk about and became good publicity for the sport.
As for Busch, he definitely shouldn’t be penalized any further; that would be stupid in my opinion. I also don’t quite no how I feel about the 24/48 swap. I understand why they did it and I just hope you’re correct in it making the 48 crew want to work harder.
by 09pmcolb on Nov 8, 2010 10:35 AM EST reply actions
Thoughts
I think the Jeff vs Jeff was exactly what you said — “boys have at it”! It was passion at its finest and was fun to watch! I have no problems with this and think it is exactly what this sport needs. Real men with real emotions! Having said that…….KB’s actions were NOT manly or professional but just the opposite! He liked like a spoil child and totally unprofessional. You should never be allowed to be disrespectful to the official in any sport and to my knowledge you aren’t allowed to and not expect to get a penalty. I actually think it is time for some thing to be done to KB that will actually get his attention. His conduct was extremely unprofessional and should not be taken lightly. I would actually like to see his owner and sponsors do something instead of NASCAR. NASCAR has already given their penalty.
The switching of pit crews seems WRONG to me. Switching during the week might be a business decision but during the race just seems wrong to me. What if the mistake had been Jimmie speeding on pit road or Chad making a call to stay out and running the car out of gas. Would someone have told Chad to go down and call the shot on Mark or Jr’s pit box?? Would Jimmie been taken out of the car and Jeff put in the car? Just how it seems to me. My opinion! Jeff – this is a great article! Loved your thoughts!
by StampinKim on Nov 8, 2010 11:00 AM EST reply actions
Great Race, Even Better Drama
Jeff vs Jeff – Boys have at it, and thank goodness they took their helmets off.
KB vs Nascar – same old, same old – and not just Kyle. A nascar official who works on pit road (I think it was Jason B, sorry if that is incorrect) tweeted something last night about being cussed out and flipped off hundreds of times. I went to look for it today to copy and paste, but couldn’t find it (seems to be deleted). Kyle had in car camera, and got busted. He’s been punished enough.
48 pit crew vs. the world – Can’t blame them for making the change, several people have pointed out it’s like pulling your QB, I completely agree.
by kwms on Nov 8, 2010 12:02 PM EST reply actions
Head Games
Fitting that the guy from Foreigner sang the anthem, huh?!
1) “Boys… Have at it!!” The theme continues. NO further driver penalties. When does JIMMIE join the mix? After the race we were joking that JJ was destroying the inside of his hauler while cursing a (Lowe’s)blue streak. As perspective, Kyle is JJ turned inside out. Really, it’s true. JJ has a temper, too, but Keeps It Inside. And I can’t imagine how people seem to forget the fiery, filthy mouthy, physically aggressive rude dude named Tony Stewart that drove for Gibbs for quite some time while collecting 2 Cup championships (and remains my fave driver with Kyle a close 2nd).
We can only hope the last 2 races up the ante even more! And 2011!
2) The 11 team has to do everything they can, which includes saying things I would usually be attributing to the 29 team. They are both doing great!
3) It was unorthodox to switch 24 for 48 crew but I can’t find anything forbidding it in the rule book, it’s like subbing a driver mid race. It’s never been a secret that Hendrick considers “The 2-4-8 Shop” to be one team with 2 cars and that has always meant Chad thinks all personnel are interchangeable (hello JG! Steve!).
4) It was great to see The Real Jeff Gordon again. The one I hated back in the 90s. Hope he gets to drive from now on.
PS I certainly don’t want driver fights every race. I’m not watching for that any more than I watch for wrecks. To me it was more symbolic, that Somebody Still Gives A Flying F*** About Racing & Shows Some Passion!!!!
by DRLDeBoer on Nov 8, 2010 12:13 PM EST reply actions
Kyle Busch should learn how to express his feelings in more subtle ways
then he may seem less like a whiner. I remember years ago, Rusty Wallace was fined by NASCAR for jumping the restart at Richmond, when he was the leader. He paid his fine in pennies, delivered via an armored truck due to the weight, because he said “NASCAR needs to get some sense”.
CTOB
-------
But it does me no injury for my neighbor to say there are twenty gods or no God. It neither picks my pocket nor breaks my leg.
-Thomas Jefferson, Notes on Virginia, 1782
by McDammit on Nov 8, 2010 6:35 PM EST reply actions
Substitutions
I commend Chad for thinking outside the pit box. However, I do not agree with the analogy of swapping crews as a player substitution. It was more like the Redskins deciding they are not playing well so they bring in the Eagles to finish the game. Despite the fact the crews work for the same employer, they are different teams with different sponsors and obligations. Teams don’t make trades in the middle of a game. That being said, I’m not bitter about it or think it should be outlawed. I agree with Mike Ford, it was a desperate move. Only time will tell if they can rebound. One more reason to tune in next week! Go Denny Go!
by Anthony Anderson on Nov 9, 2010 12:24 AM EST reply actions
are you guys kidding!
that race sucked,joe dirt movie was more exciting and i seen it 50 times,but lucky for me i did see gordon beat up burton and that was awesome!!!who gives a shit to see same so called “champ” win again,not me,go 88!!! points system sucks any way you look at it! i did miss kyles middle finger though,bummer for me,good for him,im sure official deserved it!!! is chad scared for his job awe to bad so sad! hopefully pheonix is exciting enough to not switch channels! i wanna see somebody try that shit with newman,good luck with that one, he is an animal!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
by sunvgg on Nov 11, 2010 4:39 PM EST reply actions
Comments For This Post Are Closed