Updated throughout the day with quick takes from staff.
by Kevin McCauley • Dec 18, 2011 6:01 PM EST
The Kansas City Chiefs have won their first game in the post-Todd Haley era, 19-14, simultaneously ending the winning streak of the Green Bay Packers. The Chiefs' defense was great, while the Packers did not play up to their normal standard on both sides of the ball. However, that doesn't mean that the game wasn't without a little bit of controversy.
In the fourth quarter, Leonard Pope got down to the three-yard line on a 33-yard reception, on which he lost control of the ball. The officials ruled that Pope stepped out of bounds before fumbling out of the back of the end zone. Mike McCarthy considered a challenge, but kept the flag in his pocket. Did he make a mistake? It's close, but yes.
First, here is the video of the play at full speed.
It's very tough to tell what happens, but it seems like the ball coming out and the foot coming down were nearly simultaneous. Here's an animated GIF of the exact moment, which is a little more definitive, but still leaves some doubt.
It looks like he fumbled, but it's still a little too close to call. Here's a still screenshot of the moment Pope's foot hits the chalk, for good measure.
That's a little more definitive. Now, did this call or McCarthy's decision not to challenge significantly alter the outcome of the game? No, probably not. The call is so close that the referee would have struggled to find conclusive video evidence.
The final verdict is that Pope fumbled the ball out of the back of the end zone before his foot came down, but it really was too close to call without stopping the frame. And in the end, it's McCarthy's fault for not throwing the challenge flag, not the official's fault for missing a call that close at full speed.
3 comments
Kevin McCauley:
Did Leonard Pope Fumble Or Step Out Of Bounds Against The Packers?
The 5 biggest sports stories, hand-picked for your inbox. Show more info?
We’ve developed a unique newsletter that delivers the five most interesting sports stories fans are talking about, direct to your email three times a week. Each email is curated by an SB Nation editor who follows sports the way you do: as a fan. One email three times a week, with stories worth your time.
You can unsubscribe at anytime, and we'll never use your address for evil. Not interested? Make this bar go away forever. You can always sign up later.









Comments
Even if the ref did call it a fumble, I don’t think he can conclusively say the ball made it to the end zone before going out of bounds (at least based on those angles).
by sickcoyote on Dec 18, 2011 7:41 PM EST reply actions
There are
plays like this in every game. The losing team will find some bad calls to justify the reason(s) they lost. Tamba Hali was held pretty much all game and in the end zone that would have been a safety. So what? It happens, It’s the NFL. Go Chiefs!
Arrowhead Pride Weekly
by Chiefsfan85 on Dec 18, 2011 11:50 PM EST reply actions
No way would that have been overtuned.
by bangkokhoosier on Dec 19, 2011 1:21 AM EST reply actions
Comments For This Post Are Closed