Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: King Maker: Anze Kopitar Scores OT Winner; L.A. Takes Game 1

Grumpy

FinFinatic

Sep 12, 2009 May 23, 2012 36 520

a fan of

New York Yankees Major League Baseball Team

Miami Dolphins National Football League Team

Arizona Wildcats NCAA Men's Basketball Division 1 Team

Detroit Red Wings National Hockey League Team

Iron Mike Boxer(s)

rss icon RSSUser Blog

The Phinsider Do QB ratings really matter?

People often use QB ratings as a barometer as to whether a QB is good or not, but do they really matter? You can have the highest QB rating, but if you don't win the Big dance, so what? I wanted to see if there was a direct correlation between QB ratings and whether that meant you won the Super Bowl and I was surprised by the results.

Rather than list every Super Bowl, I went back the last 11 starting in 2000, which QB's played, who won or lost, and where those QB's ranked in the regular season for QB ratings in the league.

SB YEAR Winning QB Reg Season
QB Rating
Reg
Season Rank
Losing QB Reg Season
QB Rating
Reg
Season Rank
XLV 2010 Aaron Rodgers 101.2 3 Ben Roethlisberger 97.0 5
XLIV 2009 Drew Brees 109.6 1 Peyton Manning 99.9 6
XLIII 2008 Ben Roethlisberger 80.1 24 Kurt Warner 96.9 3
XLII 2007 Eli Manning 73.9 25 Tom Brady 117.2 1
XLI 2006 Peyton Manning 101.0 1 Rex Grossman 73.9 24
XL 2005 Ben Roethlisberger 98.6 3 Matt Hasselbeck 98.2 4
XXXIX 2004 Tom Brady 92.6 9 Donovan McNabb 104.7 4
XXXVIII 2003 Tom Brady 85.9 10 Jake Delhomme 80.6 14
XXXVII 2002 Brad Johnson 92.9 3 Rich Gannon 97.3 2
XXXVI 2001 Tom Brady 86.5 6 Kurt Warner 101.4 1
XXXV 2000 Trent Dilfer 76.6 20 Kerry Collins 83.1 12
90.81 average
9.5 average 95.47 average
5.5 average

Some interesting stats:

On average, in the past 11 years, Super Bowl winning QB's had lower QB ratings (90.81) in the regular season than losing Super Bowl QB's (95.47).

In 2007, Eli Manning had a regular season QB rating of only 73.9 and won the Super Bowl, yet Tom Brady had the best regular season QB rating of 117.2 and lost.

All QB's combined average QB rating rank averaged 8.22 so if I was going to pull a stat out of a hat, this is the one would be the one I look for. Consistently Rank in the Top 8 for QB ratings and you're in the elite.

These stats show that just because you have a high QB rating, it doesn't always translate into winning the Super Bowl. Sure, you would like to have a QB with the best QB rating year in and year out, but while higher usually means better, it doesn't always mean winner.

23 comments  | 

keyword is ALMOST, mysteriously this never happens when you're winning games

My money's on Vontae lol

7 months ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 7 comments

It just keeps getting better and better, UGG

7 months ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 3 comments

Swilliams

The Dolphins are rumored to have tried out new RB Williams this week saying she's got the 'fire' the team's desperately missing.

Nahh, just kidding, I thought with all of the doom and gloom around here lately I'd make something for a laugh. Hope ya like!

8 months ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 3 comments 1 recs

Hall-of-Famer Dan Marino made his NFL debut for the Dolphins on this day in 1983.

8 months ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 1 comment

Per Jason La Canfora Tweet: Dolphins are re-signing RB Larry Johnson. Makes you wonder how ready their rookie draft pick is to get carries and pass protect.

If true, I wonder who's leaving?

9 months ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 9 comments

I apologize to Mosul for the repost, but with all of the team news lately, my original post got bumped down into the blackhole and we have 2 spots still open for tomorrows draft. If we can't fill all of the teams, we can't have a draft.

Thanks to everyone who has joined already!

I set up a Fantasy Football League at NFL.com and wanted to invite you to join my league. It's my first time doing this, so please bear with me. I thought it would be fun to give it a try and maybe some of you haven't joined a league already or want to play in another one.

12 teams, 2 divisions, 4 teams left 3 teams left 2 teams left.

Draft is Tomorrow - Tuesday, Sep 6, 2011 at 7:30pm EDT.

Private League
League ID: 644361
League Password: dolphins

I hope you'll join and good luck!!! :)

UPDATE!!! ***** ALL FULL!!!! *****

Thanks to everyone who joined, draft is tomorrow 7:30pm EDT.

9 months ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 8 comments

Hi everyone, I set up a Fantasy Football League at NFL.com and wanted to invite you to join my league. It's my first time doing this, so please bear with me. I thought it would be fun to give it a try and maybe some of you haven't joined a league already or want to play in another one.

12 teams, 2 divisions, 10 teams left.

Draft is Tuesday, Sep 6, 2011 at 7:30pm EDT.

League ID: 644361
League Password: dolphins

I hope you'll join and good luck!!! :)

*Update - only 5 spots left!

9 months ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 12 comments

After the BM incident was pretty well forgotten, Ben Volin decides to stir the pot. Ridiculous timing.

10 months ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 7 comments

Williams signed a two-year deal. It’s worth up to $4 million.

10 months ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 9 comments

A person familiar with the NFL negotiations told The Associated Press that players would not vote Wednesday on a deal to end the lockout.

This will make things interesting....

11 months ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 3 comments

That's because it never was flexed in the first place.

ESPN Stats & Information notes that 31 quarterbacks have attempted more throws that have traveled longer than 20 yards in the air than Henne has.

over 1 year ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 8 comments

Opponents have a league-high 149.8 passer rating in those situations, completing 16 of 20 passes for 239 yards and two touchdowns. They've forced zero interceptions and recorded three sacks.

ESPN Stats & Information sorts each play in about every imaginable way, and those researchers inform us when opponents send a defensive back after Bengals quarterback Carson Palmer, he shreds them.

Palmer has completed 74.5 percent of his passes for 465 yards and two touchdowns with no interceptions and four sacks, according to Stats & Information's records against added pressure from the secondary. He ranks fourth with a 119.5 passer rating.

On the flip side, Dolphins quarterback Chad Henne ranks immediately behind Palmer in this category with a 117.4 passer rating. Henne has completed 62.5 percent of his passes for 236 yards and a league-high four touchdowns. He has thrown one interception and has been sacked once.

over 1 year ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 1 comment

The Miami Dolphins signed former Dallas Cowboys fullback Deon Anderson after terminating the contract of linebacker Bobby Carpenter, who struggled on special teams.

The 5-foot-10, 245-pounder former Cowboys sixth-round draft pick was selected in the 2007 NFL draft out of Connecticut.

over 1 year ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 20 comments

Sad news. Reports are coming in from all around that NFL that Broncos WR Kenny McKinley has taken his own life. He was 23 years old. A 5th Round Draft Pick in 2009, McKinley missed all of 2009 with a knee injury. He was hoping to return to form in 2010, but another knee injury forced him back on I/R early in Training Camp.

My prayers go out to the McKinley family.

over 1 year ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 6 comments

The average Dolphin had 3.47 seasons of experience, lowest in the AFC and second-lowest in the league. They carried 13 rookies or first-year players, tied for third in the NFL. They have only four players who are 30 or older, fewest in the NFL.

The Dolphins had the second-heaviest club last year at 251.38 pounds, reflective of Bill Parcells' longstanding attitude that bigger is better. They actually got bigger this year, averaging 253.62 pounds, but dropped to third behind Parcells' previous team, the Dallas Cowboys, and the Baltimore Ravens (by two-one hundredths of a pound).

over 1 year ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 8 comments

The Phinsider Who Would You Place Your Rock In Front Of?


My wife and I are watching a Gordon Ramsey show (cooking show for those who don't know), and he did a clever thing where he had everyone that worked in the restaurant take a rock and place it in front of the person they thought was the leader. What's funny is they were all choosing different people and it quickly showed how no one was in charge.

This made me ponder the question regarding our QB's, specifically Henne & CP10.

If we asked all of the players to take a rock and put it in front of the QB they thought was the leader on the team, do you think they would all put it in front of Henne, CP10, or both, and if both, doesn't that show a leadership problem on our team to begin with?

For as much as I like CP10, I almost feel that by having him lingering as the backup, it sends a mixed message to the team as to who the leader is. I think in order for Henne to take full control of the team, the message has to be clear.

What do you think?

19 comments  | 

MIAMI DOLPHINS’ PRACTICE SQUAD

Jonathon Amaya DB 6-2 190 11/25/88 R Nevada '10 Diamond Bar, CA

Ryan Baker DE 6-5 295 11/25/84 2 Purdue ’09 Indianapolis, Ind.

Ray Feinga G 6-4 337 5/8/86 1 BYU '09 West Valley City, Utah

Chris McCoy LB 6-3 261 11/25/86 R Middle Tenn State '10 Villa Rica, GA

Nathan Overbay TE 6-5 270 1/4/87 R Eastern Washington ’10 Chehalis, Wash

Julius Pruitt WR 6-2 206 12/30/85 1 Ouachita ’09 Newport, Ark.

Austin Spitler LB 6-2 243 10/26/86 R Ohio State '10 Bellbrook, OH

over 1 year ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 5 comments

Per Omar Kelly .

Clifton Geathers is a 6-7, 300 DE from South Carolina. He was a 6th round pick of the Browns in 2010.

Joe Reitz is a 6-7, 320 OT 2nd year player from Western Michigan. He spent the last 2 seasons on the Ravens practice squad.

Robert Rose is 6-4, 297 DE who the Seahawks signed as an undrafted rookie. He played at Ohio State.

Jeremy Parnell 6-6, 290 OT was on Saints '09 practice squad last year.

Lose DE Douglas, DE Grant, OL Procter, CB W Allen (IR)

over 1 year ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 13 comments

I never understood the rules, this clears it up

over 1 year ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 3 comments

Nice article from From Tim Graham - "Polite's game is all about violence -- marrow-rattling blocks and sledgehammer runs." Couldn't have said it better myself.

almost 2 years ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 2 comments

Guess if he can't get anywhere in basketball in case of a work stoppage, he's got soccer to fall back on?

almost 2 years ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 4 comments

According to Rams sideline reporter Brian Stull of 101 ESPN in St. Louis, the Dolphins are reportedly one of the teams that is "very interested" in former BYU running back Harvey Unga.

BYU's all-time leading rusher with 3,455 yards, the 6-foot-1, 215-pound Unga is slated to work out for at least 14 NFL teams a week before the supplemental draft on July 8.

almost 2 years ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 10 comments 1 recs

URGG!

Aaron Wilson of the National Football Post reports the New England Patriots are in the lead to acquire receiver Anquan Boldin from the Arizona Cardinals.

about 2 years ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 1 comment

I don't know if playing in Florida means playing for the fins, bucs, or jags?

over 2 years ago Grumpy_tiny FinFinatic 6 comments