My Worries Have Shifted from backup 3B to OF

JodyDavis — Tue, 24 Mar 2009 15:31:48 -0000

The whole spring I've been thinking that the Cubs have an obvious hole on their bench at 3B, something that's been discussed a lot and something I felt a little better about with Koskie in camp. Now that his career sadly has come to an end, it's back to either thinking about Miles or Fontenot at 3B, or picking up one of these guys that's likely to be moved like Keppinger, Jeff Baker, or who knows, someone 'spensive like Hank Blalock?

But then I start thinking that if Fontenot can handle 3B, then it's really not so bad for him to spell Aramis here and there, and that maybe the scariest potential situations are actually in the outfield.

1) Soriano -- He has to stay healthy. Our most experienced LF on the team is currently our platoon centerfielder.

2) Fukudome -- If he does falter, then we're going to probably have Reed Johnson as the main centerfielder.

3) Reed Johnson -- Solid guy, but no power. If something happens to Soriano or Bradley, he's likely playing every day. I don't dislike the idea of him playing every day, but coupled with missing the bop of Soriano or Bradley....not as much.

4) Milton Bradley -- A very important piece, can rake, and probably will be a decent rightfielder. But he's a very likely candidate to get hurt. This is actually one position where I feel very good about a replacement, because Fukudome was outstanding in RF.

5) Joey Gathright -- Super backup OF, really helps this team on defense, especially in later innings. Can't really hit, wouldn't want him as a starter for any extended stretch of time.

6) Micah Hoffpauir -- Sort of the inverse of Gathright. Having his bat in the lineup is probably just fine most of the time. Not a very good outfielder, and will likely look worse the more he's out there.

So here's my thinking: I am perfectly fine with our best case outfield of Soriano-Reed/Fukudome-Bradley. But if and when injuries start to happen, it gets kind of scary offensively. If we have Soriano or Bradley gone for an extended amount of time, that probably means both Reed and Fukudome are starting most of the time. The defense will actually be better in that case, but we are missing a lot of sock. I don't think Gathright sees too many starts in this scenario, because his defense isn't much better than theirs, if at all, and he has no power at all. Hoffpauir might be good for a spot start or two.

I guess what I am saying is that our outfield already doesn't have all that much pop, and once you get into the backups, the only one who has power is Hoffpauir. I'd feel a lot better if we had someone who could do about what Edmonds did last year. (Not Edmonds, because I doubt he could repeat last year.) This is when I start thinking about guys like Randy Winn, who have proven they can hit and won't hurt you in the field.

And I hesitate to even mention this again, but if we had Teahen, we'd have a replacement for Gathright who could also spell Aramis.

Pick your 5th Starter

JodyDavis — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 16:36:08 -0000

With Marquis officially a Rockie, and rampant speculation on the Internets, not being helped by Hendry's intentionally vague language regarding the 5th slot in the rotation, I began to get a little juiced thinking about another starter. Shoot for the moon with Peavy? Pick up an innings horse like Tim Redding, who probably would make us wish we had Marquis back?

Here are my candidates. What do you think?

UPDATE: I done added a poll.

1) Jake Peavy

Probably the number one choice of most people, if we can afford him. Turns our rotation into probably the best in the league (SF and the Yanks might have something to say about that.) My first choice as well, and he obviously would love to be here.

2) Derek Lowe

I'd love to have him, but I can't see *any* way he comes here unless he decides he would trade ivy for the big lettuce he's looking to make. He's not as good as Peavy, but he might be the best fit of anyone out there, all things (playoff experience, groundball pitcher) considered.

3) Andy Pettitte

Hmmmmm. I don't know how much he has left, but even if it's a little, he'd be a great 5th starter on a contender. Knows how to win, pitches with his left arm. Might still be too expensive if he actually did turn down 10 million from the Yankees. I hope the Cubs at least kick the tires on him.

4) Braden Looper

My first reaction is that he'd also fit very nicely at the back end of our rotation, but then I remember having him on my fantasy team and how he often pitches only 5 or 6 innings. That might be a jaded memory or maybe I am remembering wrong, but it seems like we'd be into the bullpen a lot sooner than with some other guys, and we already have a guy like that in Harden.

5) Tim Redding

Incredibly unsexy eater of innings. He's fairly steady, but it would be pretty disappointing after all the fun speculation about who might be available to end up with this guy. If I didn't think we'd need Gaudin for spot starts and long relief, I'd prefer Gaudin over him.

6) Chad Gaudin

I certainly think he can do the job well enough, but not having him in the pen for 2 or 3 inning stints when needed hurts the team I think, especially when he's not likely to pitch more than 6 innings himself, thereby magnifyling his absence from the pen.

7) Sean Marshall

I don't know what to think about him. I'd really love to see him get a shot at being a full time starter; at the very least we can see if he's any good at it. BUT, we might make better use of him in the pen. I still don't trust Cotts very much. It's times like these it would be great to have Sean Gallagher back. Of course, then we'd still need another starter or two...

8) You tell me!

Poll

Who fills out the rotation?

Jake Peavy

34 votes

Derek Lowe

4 votes

Andy Pettitte

1 votes

Braden Looper

0 votes

Randy Wolf

4 votes

Ben Sheets

3 votes

Tim Redding

0 votes

Sean Marshall

29 votes

Chad Gaudin