Commented Their peripherals are pretty similar, with Cole giving up more homers on Jameson Taillon, Gerrit Cole Make FSL All-Star Team on Bucs Dugout - 06/01/12 1:43 PM EDT

Commented *no one considered giving him $40 million per season on Most Valuable Players In April And May on Bucs Dugout - 06/01/12 1:34 PM EDT

Commented It's definitely not a good model on Most Valuable Players In April And May on Bucs Dugout - 06/01/12 1:33 PM EDT (2 replies)

Commented The reason why "should we trade for Youk" doesn't get over 200 responses on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 06/01/12 1:24 PM EDT

Commented Does anyone know on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 06/01/12 11:53 AM EDT

Commented "I'd offer Heredia, Grossman, Kingham, and D'Arnaud and Walk" on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 06/01/12 8:54 AM EDT

Commented Yuck on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 06/01/12 8:31 AM EDT

Commented I'm not exactly sure what your question is on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 06/01/12 8:07 AM EDT

Commented Why do you see his walk rate this season as a trend on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 8:31 PM EDT (3 replies)

Commented And if we don't blow it on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 8:27 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented Somehow I doubt the Bucs taking on $18 million per year for a 4th OFer on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 8:25 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented No, its not on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 8:23 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented Shhhhhh on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 8:01 PM EDT

Commented There are degrees of projection on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 7:59 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented Do you buy his significant increase in stolen bases? on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 7:58 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented Walker was a good player the last two seasons on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 7:47 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented "true slugger" on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 7:46 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented RIGHT NOW on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 7:37 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented This on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 7:35 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented This "one piece away" mantra doesn't make sense on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 7:33 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented Exactly on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 7:26 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented Castro's WAR on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 7:24 PM EDT

Commented I'll take this in a different direction on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 7:16 PM EDT (2 replies)

Commented The #70 prospect in baseball + scraps on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 7:11 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented Soriano on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 7:02 PM EDT

Commented That age thing on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 7:01 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented A few points on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 7:00 PM EDT (2 replies)

Commented Ichiro was a better hitter on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 6:47 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented And the BABIP thing on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 6:34 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented Since I don't think it has been brought up yet on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 6:27 PM EDT (2 replies)

Commented Along with his lack of elite power, that's one of the reasons why on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 6:22 PM EDT

Commented Sorry I butchered those block quotes. Obviously that last part in the box is my words. on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 6:19 PM EDT

Commented Then add two players on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 6:18 PM EDT

Commented Rebuttal on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 6:17 PM EDT (2 replies)

Commented All that matters is whether it's a +EV gamble on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 6:02 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented I think he was just trying to point out on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 5:17 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented I ran the numbers in a previous thread the other day on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 5:13 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented We'd have Castro for another 4 seasons on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 4:51 PM EDT

Commented Castro has had consistently very high BABIPs through his MiLB and MLB careers on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 4:47 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented Wow. on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 4:47 PM EDT (4 replies)

Commented I'd be interested to compare J-Mac's trade value to Cole and Taillon's on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 4:35 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented Taillon or Cole + a B prospect on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 4:30 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented GFJ is one data point on Who Would you give up for Starlin Castro? on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 4:22 PM EDT (2 replies)

Commented This needs to be greened on Matt Hague's Clutch Hit Helps Pirates Beat Johnny Cueto, Reds on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 3:50 PM EDT

Recommended Instead, we are more likely on Bucs Dugout - 05/31/12 3:50 PM EDT

Commented oh the ironing on Worst Play Ever A Lowlight In Pirates' 8-1 Drubbing By Reds on Bucs Dugout - 05/30/12 2:42 PM EDT

Commented i agree on Worst Play Ever A Lowlight In Pirates' 8-1 Drubbing By Reds on Bucs Dugout - 05/30/12 2:31 PM EDT (3 replies)

Commented Other teams would likely see Tabata as a gamble on Worst Play Ever A Lowlight In Pirates' 8-1 Drubbing By Reds on Bucs Dugout - 05/30/12 2:08 PM EDT

Commented This was the worst article that has ever been posted on the internet on Worst Play Ever A Lowlight In Pirates' 8-1 Drubbing By Reds on Bucs Dugout - 05/30/12 2:05 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented As he ages ... on Worst Play Ever A Lowlight In Pirates' 8-1 Drubbing By Reds on Bucs Dugout - 05/30/12 2:03 PM EDT

Commented Castro's MiLB BABIPs: on Worst Play Ever A Lowlight In Pirates' 8-1 Drubbing By Reds on Bucs Dugout - 05/30/12 2:01 PM EDT

Commented FWIW I think picking up Soriano and Castro would be a good move, in theory on Worst Play Ever A Lowlight In Pirates' 8-1 Drubbing By Reds on Bucs Dugout - 05/30/12 12:34 PM EDT (2 replies)

Commented The Gettysburg Address on OT: Attractions, events, and things to do in the Pittsburgh area on Bucs Dugout - 05/30/12 1:32 AM EDT

Commented And yea, I think NH should probably be fired on Let's give credit where credit is due on Bucs Dugout - 05/30/12 1:25 AM EDT (1 reply)

Commented I think that's not really being fair to NH on Let's give credit where credit is due on Bucs Dugout - 05/30/12 1:23 AM EDT (1 reply)

Commented I figured starting off the comments in a way that instigates 300 replies on Worst Play Ever A Lowlight In Pirates' 8-1 Drubbing By Reds on Bucs Dugout - 05/29/12 11:58 PM EDT

Commented I think the title of this article should have been: on Worst Play Ever A Lowlight In Pirates' 8-1 Drubbing By Reds on Bucs Dugout - 05/29/12 11:55 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented Gorksy hitting for Cutch on Reds Vs. Pirates, 29 May 2012 on Bucs Dugout - 05/29/12 11:31 PM EDT

Commented I'd sell high on J-Mac if it meant getting Machado on Pirates Back To .500 After James McDonald, Pedro Alvarez Key 4-1 Victory on Bucs Dugout - 05/29/12 11:34 AM EDT (1 reply)

Commented IIRC they did the same thing with Walker his last year at AAA on Pirates Back To .500 After James McDonald, Pedro Alvarez Key 4-1 Victory on Bucs Dugout - 05/29/12 11:32 AM EDT (1 reply)

Commented Ah, there's that sabermetric arrogance that turns people off on Stats: Descriptive and Predictive on Bucs Dugout - 05/29/12 11:06 AM EDT (1 reply)

Recommended Pedro>Graphs on Bucs Dugout - 05/29/12 11:01 AM EDT

Recommended It's probably some type of regression. on Bucs Dugout - 05/29/12 11:01 AM EDT

Commented on Pirates Back To .500 After James McDonald, Pedro Alvarez Key 4-1 Victory on Bucs Dugout - 05/29/12 10:58 AM EDT

Recommended Do you mean Pythagoras or Youkilis? on Bucs Dugout - 05/29/12 10:54 AM EDT

Commented I agree 100% on Let's give credit where credit is due on Bucs Dugout - 05/29/12 10:39 AM EDT (1 reply)

Commented lol on Pirates Back To .500 After James McDonald, Pedro Alvarez Key 4-1 Victory on Bucs Dugout - 05/29/12 4:31 AM EDT

Commented Crap on Pirates Back To .500 After James McDonald, Pedro Alvarez Key 4-1 Victory on Bucs Dugout - 05/29/12 12:00 AM EDT (1 reply)

Commented Anything with club options on Pirates Back To .500 After James McDonald, Pedro Alvarez Key 4-1 Victory on Bucs Dugout - 05/28/12 11:59 PM EDT

Commented 4.03 xFIP on Pirates Back To .500 After James McDonald, Pedro Alvarez Key 4-1 Victory on Bucs Dugout - 05/28/12 11:56 PM EDT (2 replies)

Commented I concur on Pirates Back To .500 After James McDonald, Pedro Alvarez Key 4-1 Victory on Bucs Dugout - 05/28/12 11:52 PM EDT (2 replies)

Commented McDonald extension on Pirates Back To .500 After James McDonald, Pedro Alvarez Key 4-1 Victory on Bucs Dugout - 05/28/12 11:42 PM EDT (2 replies)

Commented Although to clarify on Pirates Back To .500 After James McDonald, Pedro Alvarez Key 4-1 Victory on Bucs Dugout - 05/28/12 11:39 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented I agree with this on Pirates Back To .500 After James McDonald, Pedro Alvarez Key 4-1 Victory on Bucs Dugout - 05/28/12 11:39 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented he was also known for hyperbole on Pirates Back To .500 After James McDonald, Pedro Alvarez Key 4-1 Victory on Bucs Dugout - 05/28/12 11:35 PM EDT (1 reply)

Commented +1, well said on Pirates Back To .500 After James McDonald, Pedro Alvarez Key 4-1 Victory on Bucs Dugout - 05/28/12 11:33 PM EDT

Commented Haha, first comment was better than mine. on Pirates Back To .500 After James McDonald, Pedro Alvarez Key 4-1 Victory on Bucs Dugout - 05/28/12 9:47 PM EDT

Recommended Nobody panic. on Bucs Dugout - 05/28/12 9:46 PM EDT

Commented A win is nice, on Pirates Back To .500 After James McDonald, Pedro Alvarez Key 4-1 Victory on Bucs Dugout - 05/28/12 9:46 PM EDT (3 replies)

Commented Fortunately, for us on Neal Huntington: Pirates Will Make Big Trade Only If It's 'The Right Deal' on Bucs Dugout - 05/28/12 11:26 AM EDT (1 reply)