He'd cost considerably less (no Wallace), he's only making 3.5 million this year, he can play first, second, third, or either corner OF spot.  He's an average defensive 3B and a league average hitter who will give us basically identical splits against righties and lefties

LH : 302/.348/.421

RH: 292/.354/464

As you can see, he has a little more power against righties, but still gets on at the same clip against either type of pitcher. Tony would love his versatility, and I can't imagine he'd cost any more than say Boggs/Mortensen and a C+ prospect.

That would give you an everyday lineup of:

1. 2B/LF Skip

2. 2B/3B/LF. Teahen

3. 1B. Pujols

4. RF. Ludwick

5. 2B/3B/LF DeRosa

6. CF. Rasmus

7. C Molina

8. P

9. SS Ryan

With Lugo, Ankiel, LaRue, Thurston, and Stavinoha rounding out your bench.