I like this approach

Just a fan's view.

Moved it just for you spants. I guess you didn't read the part before about this was just a "for fun" idea. Not serious. Loosen your belt dude, who do you think you are going off like that.

My wife and I were talking about all the different line ups and came up with this one, just for fun, based on order of jersey number...so it would look something like this. Some players may be skipped simply because the fielding position is already filled

#4 Molina C

#5 Pujols 1B

#7 DeRosa 3B

#13 Ryan SS

#16 Duncan LF

#22 Thurston 2B

#24 Ankiel RF

#28 Rasmus CF

#29 Carpenter(or other pitcher)

See that was fun!