yankee fan here (i come in peace lol)

This is becoming a major debate in yankeeland, if the Yankees traded for Halladay they would obviously need to trade either Joba or Hughes. Some don't want to give up Joba and the same goes for Hughes.

Lets just say a trade does happen between the Yanks and Jays, who would you prefer to recieve in that trade, Joba Chamberlain or Phil Hughes?

(obviously this is all rhetorically speaking and obviously other prospects beside joba/hughes would need to be involved in the trade)