Commented command on Henderson Alvarez on Minor League Ball - 02/13/12 7:24 PM EST

Commented He has been working on the slider and it hasn't progressed like it should on Henderson Alvarez on Minor League Ball - 02/13/12 7:22 PM EST

Commented didn't like his choice of books on Keith Law top 100 Prospects on Minor League Ball - 02/13/12 7:06 PM EST

Commented I think you would have two options on Prospect Analysis: Elite Prospects from 2007 on Minor League Ball - 02/13/12 2:12 PM EST

Commented why wouldn't he just scan it in? sounds crazy to use data entry when scanning exists on Prospect Analysis: Elite Prospects from 2007 on Minor League Ball - 02/13/12 1:43 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented I don't think he could hit a breaking ball on Prospect Analysis: Elite Prospects from 2007 on Minor League Ball - 02/13/12 1:41 PM EST

Commented Profar on Kevin Goldstein's BP top 101 Prospects on Minor League Ball - 02/13/12 1:29 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented straight as an arrow? on Henderson Alvarez on Minor League Ball - 02/13/12 12:16 PM EST

Commented exactly, that is the problem on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 9:59 PM EST

Commented normally I prefer stats to eyesight on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 9:58 PM EST

Commented not a Sox fan, just a huge fan of Martinez on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 9:53 PM EST

Commented Both pitches have the exact same motion on Henderson Alvarez on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 9:32 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented I get where you are coming from on Keith Law top 100 Prospects on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 9:16 PM EST

Commented there are minor changes like improving a curve, etc. on Keith Law top 100 Prospects on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 4:25 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented His stuff wasn't seen as elite because until Webb, Lowe, Wang, etc. on Keith Law top 100 Prospects on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 4:18 PM EST

Commented mr.maniac is just making snarky comments implying that since the Rays don't have a lot of fans on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 4:12 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented Because WAR is giving him as much or more value on D on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 4:10 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented yeah, that on Keith Law top 100 Prospects on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 1:08 PM EST

Commented He worked for BP and then was hired by the Jays as a stats guy on Keith Law top 100 Prospects on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 11:46 AM EST

Commented That's the take I have on Keith Law top 100 Prospects on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 11:44 AM EST (1 reply)

Commented Maybe you just word things in a rigid way ;) on Keith Law top 100 Prospects on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 11:42 AM EST

Commented So you don't see Miggy winning gold gloves at 3B any time soon? on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 11:39 AM EST

Commented I thought this as well - but the limit seems higher than what the collective is spending right now on Budgeting for Latin American Prospects on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 11:35 AM EST

Commented Agreed on Budgeting for Latin American Prospects on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 11:34 AM EST

Commented you see things in such a rigid way on Keith Law top 100 Prospects on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 12:35 AM EST (2 replies)

Commented really? the part where I agreed having a name was important? on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 12:19 AM EST

Commented if you don't have anything constructive then dont bother on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 12:16 AM EST (1 reply)

Commented yes I have a basis on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 12:16 AM EST (1 reply)

Commented an awful lot of guesses around here on Budgeting for Latin American Prospects on Minor League Ball - 02/12/12 12:12 AM EST (1 reply)

Commented "he’s not a professional talent evaluator" on Keith Law top 100 Prospects on Minor League Ball - 02/11/12 1:15 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented Kemp, Bautista, Pujols, Tulo, Miggy, Braun, Cano on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/11/12 12:38 PM EST (3 replies)

Commented definitely, because if not he will need huge power numbers or a very high average on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/11/12 1:02 AM EST

Commented totally disagree on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/11/12 12:47 AM EST (1 reply)

Commented The immediate year after Votto was equal or better than the All-star selection on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/11/12 12:41 AM EST (2 replies)

Commented the same Mauer who was 3rd in voting last year and had a 501 OPS at the June 29 cutoff date? on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/10/12 11:11 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented so what you are saying is the 1st year Hosmer is the best he likely wont get the starting gig? on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/10/12 11:06 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented how does a player get name value? By being one of the best on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/10/12 10:59 PM EST (3 replies)

Commented so a small market Mauer getting the all-star start is somehow proof a small market Hosmer can not? on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/10/12 8:16 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented Pujols 2010 pre-ASG: 308/416/576 on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/10/12 7:50 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented so your logic is that small market players wont make the all star game but they can be beaten out by small market players? on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/10/12 7:45 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented and your argument was that point was incorrect because Votto should have started an ASG on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/10/12 7:44 PM EST

Commented Votto didnt deserve to start simple as that on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/10/12 4:44 PM EST (2 replies)

Commented oops on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/10/12 4:43 PM EST

Commented Votto on Eric Hosmer: All Star First Baseman? on Minor League Ball - 02/10/12 4:20 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented One thing that stands out is the complete lack of power for Mathis after 2005 on Catch-22: Is Travis D’Arnaud the ‘Next One?’ on Minor League Ball - 02/09/12 5:12 PM EST (2 replies)

Commented another way to look at it on Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/09/12 4:48 PM EST

Commented FWIW he is another that has seen Kelly a lot on Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/09/12 12:08 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented no worries, I felt you had a lot to contribute and preferred you write on Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/09/12 1:21 AM EST (1 reply)

Commented maybe I was drunk lol, or my eyesight is going on Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/09/12 1:08 AM EST

Commented +1 for me as well on Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/08/12 9:50 PM EST

Commented It was on that link you gave me on Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/08/12 9:48 PM EST (1 reply)

Recommended Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/08/12 9:46 PM EST

Commented definitely agree with you there on Are we underrating Manny Banuelos? on Minor League Ball - 02/08/12 9:23 PM EST

Commented all fairly small and correctable flaws btw on Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/08/12 9:19 PM EST

Commented I have seen him fall off to either side on Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/08/12 9:18 PM EST (3 replies)

Commented agreed on Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/08/12 9:15 PM EST

Commented hey, you know the Braves well so we appreciate the input on Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/08/12 9:11 PM EST

Commented Im basing it on what Jeff wrote on bullpenbanter on Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/08/12 7:20 PM EST (2 replies)

Commented what part of their scouting do you disagree on? on Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/08/12 5:43 PM EST (2 replies)

Commented definitely scouts talk on Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/08/12 4:39 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented I dont think scouts ever take into account the opinion of other scouts on Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/08/12 3:45 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented I think his advantage in athleticism and mechanics on Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/08/12 3:42 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented as opposed to what though? on Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/08/12 3:22 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented pitchers rarely have good command to start with on Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/08/12 3:15 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented I think this point is severly underestimated here on Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/08/12 2:54 PM EST (1 reply)

Commented I disagree with a lot there on Bullpen Banter's Top 100 Prospects: 100-51 on Minor League Ball - 02/08/12 2:52 PM EST (2 replies)

Commented I figured as much, especially since his numbers were good but not great on The Elite Pitching Prospects: 2003 through 2006 on Minor League Ball - 02/08/12 9:18 AM EST

Commented You are picking one and only one stat to determine if he is grade A? on The Elite Pitching Prospects: 2003 through 2006 on Minor League Ball - 02/07/12 9:21 PM EST (3 replies)

Commented I remember the big push for relievers to be rated higher. Maybe that is why they seem to be underrated now? on The Elite Pitching Prospects: 2003 through 2006 on Minor League Ball - 02/07/12 3:53 PM EST

Commented In hindsight on The Elite Pitching Prospects: 2003 through 2006 on Minor League Ball - 02/07/12 3:44 PM EST (2 replies)

Commented the only question on his power was about whether he would recover on The Congo Hammer's Top 50 AL Prospects on Minor League Ball - 02/07/12 2:23 PM EST

Commented Paxton on Help me pick one for Fantasy on Minor League Ball - 02/07/12 2:11 PM EST

Commented while he should be up before then I doubt he is a force until 2016 on Help me pick one for Fantasy on Minor League Ball - 02/07/12 2:08 PM EST (1 reply)

Recommended a comment on Minor League Ball - 02/07/12 2:04 PM EST

Commented further on Are we underrating Manny Banuelos? on Minor League Ball - 02/04/12 12:57 AM EST (1 reply)

Commented most scouts see a player the level of Banuelos a half dozen times on Are we underrating Manny Banuelos? on Minor League Ball - 02/04/12 12:53 AM EST

Commented you saw him one time, isnt that a serious case of confirmation bias? on Are we underrating Manny Banuelos? on Minor League Ball - 02/03/12 2:26 AM EST (1 reply)

Commented Up until 2010 you can find the data you want below on Pitches per start in MiLB on Minor League Ball - 02/02/12 2:12 AM EST

Commented you seem biased but it appears to be more of a bias on your one time viewing Banuelos on Are we underrating Manny Banuelos? on Minor League Ball - 02/02/12 12:02 AM EST (1 reply)

Commented that makes a lot of sense on Who would you rather have.... on Minor League Ball - 02/01/12 11:58 PM EST