clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

College Football BlogPoll Top 25, Week 4: Raising Arizona

A relatively tranquil week sees Arizona and Iowa nearly swap spots; Wisconsin is punished for a skin-of-its-PAT-block escape and Stanford rewarded for beating the demon out of the Deacons. Plus: people still voting for Virginia Tech!

Getty Images

A relatively tranquil week with Iowa's loss to Arizona the main souhce of big moves; the two teams nearly swap places. Nevada and Michigan State surge through the "others receiving votes" section to grab on at the tail end of the poll, Stanford and Arkansas slide up after crushing weaklings and notching a quality win, respectively, and everything else pretty much stays the same.

We are seeing some strange No. 1 votes pop up, with Oregon, TCU, Oklahoma, and Stanford gathering No. 1's; one dollar our wackiest wack voter is the Stanford proponent after the Cardinal laid waste to Wake Forest this weekend.

In any case, the poll:

SB Nation BlogPoll Top 25 College Football Rankings

Results for Week 4

# School Points/blog SD Delta
1 Alabama Crimson Tide (85) 24.7 0.80 --
2 Ohio St. Buckeyes (14) 23.6 1.76 --
3 Oregon Ducks (1) 21.0 3.82 --
4 TCU Horned Frogs (1) 20.7 2.67 --
5 Boise St. Broncos 19.9 3.93 --
6 Nebraska Cornhuskers 19.5 3.17 Arrow_up 2
7 Texas Longhorns 18.7 2.74 --
8 Oklahoma Sooners (2) 18.6 3.00 Arrow_down -2
9 Florida Gators 15.5 3.76 Arrow_up 1
10 Arkansas Razorbacks 13.9 3.54 Arrow_up 4
11 Arizona Wildcats 13.3 5.04 Arrow_up 9
12 South Carolina Gamecocks 12.9 4.08 --
13 Stanford Cardinal (1) 12.2 4.34 Arrow_up 4
14 Utah Utes 11.9 4.52 Arrow_down -1
15 Wisconsin Badgers 11.6 4.38 Arrow_down -4
16 LSU Tigers 11.0 4.63 Arrow_down -1
17 Auburn Tigers 10.4 4.01 Arrow_down -1
18 Iowa Hawkeyes 6.5 3.80 Arrow_down -9
19 Miami Hurricanes 6.1 4.49 --
20 Michigan Wolverines 6.0 4.02 Arrow_down -2
21 USC Trojans 4.1 4.31 --
22 West Virginia Mountaineers 3.8 3.39 Arrow_up 3
23 Penn St. Nittany Lions 3.4 3.32 Arrow_down -1
24 Nevada Wolf Pack 2.6 3.85 Arrow_up 18
25 Michigan St. Spartans 2.5 3.07 Arrow_up 11
Others Receiving Votes: Oklahoma St. Cowboys | Oregon St. Beavers | Missouri Tigers | Air Force Falcons | N.C. State Wolfpack | Fresno St. Bulldogs | Pittsburgh Panthers | Florida St. Seminoles | Clemson Tigers | Kansas St. Wildcats | Texas A&M Aggies | Temple Owls | Northwestern Wildcats | California Golden Bears | Boston College Eagles | Kentucky Wildcats | Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets | Georgia Bulldogs | Rutgers Scarlet Knights | Virginia Tech Hokies | Houston Cougars | BYU Cougars | South Florida Bulls | North Carolina Tar Heels | Arizona St. Sun Devils | Southern Miss. Golden Eagles
Updated: Sep 22, 2010 7:43 AM PDT

Total Ballots: 104

Explore votes by team
Explore poll ballots by voter

On with the bonus stuff:

Justify Your Existence

The BlogPoll loves:

  • No. 3 Oregon (No. 5 AP, No. 6 coaches)
  • No. 11 Arizona (No. 14 AP, No. 16 coaches)
  • No. 12 South Carolina (No. 15 coaches)
  • No. 13 Stanford No. 16 AP, No. 17 coaches)
  • No. 24 Nevada (UR)

The BlogPoll hates:

  • No. 5 Boise State (No. 3 both other polls)
  • No. 7 Texas (No. 4 coaches)
  • No. 15 Wisconsin (No. 10 coaches, No. 11 AP)
  • No. 16 LSU (No. 12 coaches, No. 15 AP)

Looks good to me, as it pays attention to Oregon's demolition, VT's implosion, and how good Stanford looks while taking Texas's iffy play and Wisconsin's narrow escape into account. This is why the resume guys are fine in aggregate: they make the poll more responsive to early season events.

Wack Ballot Watchdog

  • I guess this counts as progress: we're down to three inexplicable Virginia Tech votes instead of last week's five. Georgia, now 0-2 in the SEC, is hanging on to two votes, as is Houston.
  • Frank Helps You Think It All Out has USC No. 8, three spots higher than the next most enthusiastic Trojan voter.
  • Random single votes: USF's win over Stony Brook, demolition at the hands of Florida, and bye is enough for Shakin' The Southland to drop the Bulls in at No. 22. BYU is still feeling the love from Orange:44.
  • Frank The Tank's Slant (not a good week for the Franks) has Oregon State, not Oregon, No. 4 in what must be a ballot typo.
  • In what must be a first for the universe, Red Cup Rebellion's ballot features Temple No. 17 and Oregon No. 18. The next most pessimistic on Oregon has them No. 13.
  • What's with three voters having Oklahoma State (Ws: WSU, Troy by three, Tulsa) No. 11?
  • Cal gets votes at No. 16 and No. 20 from Hey Jenny Slater and Cowboys Ride For Free; the latter doesn't even bother to rank Nevada.

Now on to the extracurriculars. First up are the teams which spur the most and least disagreement between voters as measured by standard deviation. Note that the standard deviation charts halt at #25 when looking for the lowest, otherwise teams that everyone agreed were terrible (say, Eastern Michigan) would all be at the top.

# School Points/blog SD
1 Arizona Wildcats 13.3 5.04
2 LSU Tigers 11.0 4.63
3 Utah Utes 11.9 4.52
4 Miami Hurricanes 6.1 4.49
5 Wisconsin Badgers 11.6 4.38

Michigan falls from #1 here out of the top five after their weak performance against I-AA UMass and losses from UConn and Notre Dame pushed them well down in the eyes of the resume folk. Your new champion is Arizona. With votes ranging from No. 2 to No. 25 it's no wonder.

Ballot Math

First up are "Mr. Bold" and "Mr. Numb Existence." The former goes to the voter with the ballot most divergent from the poll at large. The number you see is the average difference between a person's opinion of a team and the poll's opinion.

Mr. Bold

# Blog Team Ballot Avg Error
1 Black Heart Gold Pants Iowa Hawkeyes ballot 6.22
2 Boys of Old Florida Florida Gators ballot 6.19
3 The Purple Wimple TCU Horned Frogs ballot 5.93
4 Red Cup Rebellion Mississippi Rebels ballot 5.82
5 SB Nation Atlanta Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets ballot 4.82

Reader, you owe me a dollar. BHGP and their approach to voting, which is like resume voting except integrated (in a calculus way, not a segregation way), spends the first month of the season merrily voting whichever team has bludgeoned weak opposition #1 since all they pay attention to is margin of victory. This week that approach sees Stanford—which admittedly obliterated Wake Forest and saw their 35-0 win over UCLA pick up considerably more cachet after the Bruins clobbered Houston—leap to No. 1. Since they're No. 13 in the poll at large this is a great start towards having the weirdest ballot in all the land, and for the second straight week BHGP takes it home.

This week it's close, at least. Maybe we'll start to get some variety in the top finishers here; IIRC the top four here have been constant since the season started.

Mr. Numb Existence

# Blog Team Ballot Avg Error
1 Baltimore Sports Report Maryland Terrapins ballot 0.98
2 The Key Play Virginia Tech Hokies ballot 1.65
3 Eleven Warriors Ohio State Buckeyes ballot 1.71
4 Hog Database Arkansas Razorbacks ballot 1.77
5 The Only Colors Michigan St. Spartans ballot 1.85

The Baltimore Sports Report is also a repeat winner here, following up an impressively low error with an even more impressively low error, sliding under 1 in the third week of the season. Quest For The Perfect Ballot ends at 3, though, where TCU flips with Oregon.

Next we have the Coulter/Kos Award and the Straight Bangin' Award, which are again different sides of the same coin. The CKA and SBA go to the blogs with the highest and lowest bias rating, respectively. Bias rating is calculated by subtracting the blogger's vote for his own team from the poll-wide average. A high number indicates you are a shameless home. A low number indicates that you suffer from an abusive relationship with your football team.

The CK Award

# Blog Team Ballot Bias
1 Mountain West Connection Utah Utes ballot 6.08
2 Hog Database Arkansas Razorbacks ballot 2.11
3 Corn Nation Nebraska Cornhuskers ballot 1.48
4 The Owl's Nest Temple Owls ballot 0.71
5 Boys of Old Florida Florida Gators ballot 0.49

This week The CK Award had its most Vegas outing ever, as last week's winner was USC, a 13 point favorite over Minnesota on Wednesday but only 11.5-point favorites at kickoff. USC proceeded to struggle, falling behind for eight seconds in the second half. They then failed to cover because Lane Kiffin went for two (for no reason) three times, going 0-fer in the process and turning a spread-covering two-touchdown win into a decidedly not spread-covering 11-point win.

If you were wondering what that was all about during the game, now you know: TrojanWire voted USC too high last week. The CK award is now 3-0 against the spread this year, 1-2 straight up in trying circumstances.

This weeks whammy falls to Utah. The Mountain West Connection has them No. 8, thus exposing them to the terrible trials of the CK Award in the game against...aww, come on...San Jose State. Utah is a 32-point favorit. Can't anyone overrate their team the week they have a real game?

The Straight Bangin' Award

# Blog Team Ballot Bias
1 The Purple Wimple TCU Horned Frogs ballot -12.66
2 Black Heart Gold Pants Iowa Hawkeyes ballot -6.52
3 SpartyMSU Michigan St. Spartans ballot -1.54
4 Tomahawk Nation Florida State Seminoles ballot -0.60
5 Block-C Clemson Tigers ballot -0.57

I've pretty much given up on any attempts to figure out what moves The Purple Wimple to vote the way it does, but they have TCU 18th. They are up 4 after last week, for what it's worth. Boise is 13th despite Oregon State being a much better win than Virginia Tech right now. The man is a walking wach ballot.

Swing is the total change in each ballot from last week to the week (oviously voters who didn't submit a ballot last week are not included). A high number means you are easily distracted by shiny things. A low number means that you're damn sure you're right no matter what reality says.

Mr. Manic Depressive

# Blog Team Ballot Swing
1 Black Heart Gold Pants Iowa Hawkeyes ballot 254
2 Boys of Old Florida Florida Gators ballot 212
3 The Purple Wimple TCU Horned Frogs ballot 208
4 Red Cup Rebellion Mississippi Rebels ballot 194
5 Tom Fornelli Notre Dame Fighting Irish ballot 134


Mr. Xanax

# Blog Team Ballot Swing
1 The Owl's Nest Temple Owls ballot 32
2 Voodoo Five South Florida Bulls ballot 50
3 OverThePylon Ball St. Cardinals ballot 52
4 The Key Play Virginia Tech Hokies ballot 64
5 SpartyMSU Michigan St. Spartans ballot 66

Week 3 makes The Owl's Nest feel goooooooood, as the only major changes on its ballot are moving Iowa down and Arizona up after Arizona's win. The bottom of the poll also shuffles Michigan State and...yup...Temple, the latter after Temple basically did what Michigan did to UConn, greatly displeasing both of the BCS schools.