clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Bracketology 2012: Who Gets The Final Top Seed?

Michigan State holds it in our Selection Sunday morning bracket projection, but expect a change if the Spartans fail to win the Big Ten title this afternoon.

Getty Images

The moment of reckoning is almost upon us. Here's a rundown of some of the major moves made since Saturday morning's projection, featuring the TV information for today's four conference championship games, the final ones of 2012.

With that information out of the way, here's my penultimate projection.

Teams that have clinched automatic bids appear in all caps.

Atlanta (Fri/Sun)
(2) EAST
Boston (Thu/Sat)
Louisville (Thu/Sat) Pittsburgh (Thu/Sat)
1 Kentucky (SEC) 1 Syracuse
8 Iowa State 8 Kansas State
9 Connecticut 9 HARVARD (Ivy)
Portland (Thu/Sat) Portland (Thu/Sat)
12 COLORADO (Pac-12) 12 BYU
4 Indiana 4 Wisconsin
13 SOUTH DAKOTA ST. (Summit) 13 N.C. State/Seton Hall
Albuquerque (Thu/Sat) Columbus (Fri/Sun)
6 Notre Dame 6 Vanderbilt
11 VCU (CAA) 11 Colorado State
3 Baylor 3 Michigan
Greensboro (Fri/Sun) Omaha (Fri/Sun)
7 San Diego State 7 Cincinnati
10 Saint Louis 10 Southern Miss.
2 Duke 2 MISSOURI (Big 12)
(4) WEST
Phoenix (Thu/Sat)
St. Louis (Fri/Sun)
Columbus (Fri/Sun) Greensboro (Fri/Sun)
1 Michigan State (Big Ten) 1 North Carolina (ACC)
8 ST. MARY'S (WCC) 8 Gonzaga
9 Xavier (A-10) 9 Alabama
Nashville (Fri/Sun) Albuquerque (Thu/Sat)
5 NEW MEXICO (MWC) 5 Wichita State
12 LONG BEACH STATE (Big West) 12 Texas
4 Florida State 4 Georgetown
13 USF/Drexel 13 DAVIDSON (Southern)
Nashville (Fri/Sun) Pittsburgh (Thu/Sat)
11 Virginia 11 California
3 LOUISVILLE (Big East) 3 Marquette
Omaha (Fri/Sun) Louisville (Thu/Sat)
7 Florida 7 UNLV
10 Purdue 10 West Virginia
2 Kansas 2 Ohio State
15 DETROIT (Horizon) 15 LEHIGH (Patriot)
Tuesday: To Louisville
Tuesday: To Portland
16 MISS. VALLEY ST. (SWAC) 13 N.C. State
16 WESTERN KENTUCKY (Sun Belt) 13 Seton Hall
Wednesday: To Greensboro Wednesday: To Nashville
16 VERMONT (AmEast) 13 USF

An explanation of the Last Four In and First Four Out, along with a few more teams, follows the rundown.

Big East: 10
Colorado State Colorado Akron
Big Ten: 7 California Ohio Arizona
Big 12: 6 BYU Seton Hall Mississippi State
ACC: 5 Texas Vermont Stony Brook
MWC: 4
SEC: 4
N.C. State Harvard Up to a 9 from a 10
A-10: 3 USF Purdue Down to a 10 from a 9
WCC: 3 Seton Hall

CAA: 2 Drexel


MVC: 2 Marshall

Pac-12: 2 Dayton

1-Bid Conferences: 19 Mississippi

Mississippi State






Last Four In

After comparing the profiles for this season's bubble teams with those from 2011, the first season of the 68-team field, and 2009 and 2010, the final two years of the 65-team bracket, it seems apparent that the Selection Committee will assign teams with a variety of profile issues to Dayton to sort things out amongst themselves. This is the approach I've taken in naming the final four teams in this projection. Of course, this may not be the exact combination they favor in Indianapolis. I also may very well change my mind between now and my final bracket, so stay tuned.

Each team is presented with a list of pros and cons for selection, so you can feel the frustration I have over the past few weeks.

All records and RPI and SOS are accurate through games played on Saturday, March 10, 2012 and are courtesy Records only reflect games against Division I competition, per Selection Committee standards.

N.C. State (22-12, 11-8 ACC, RPI: 49, SOS: 32, non-conf. SOS: 63)
Pros: Has head-to-head victories over fellow bubble teams Virginia, Miami (twice) and Texas. Won four in a row, and three away from home, before closing the regular season with a loss to North Carolina in controversial circumstances. Won relatively frequently away from Raleigh (9-6).

Cons: Owns just one win against the RPI Top 50, compared with nine losses (including three in a row to Duke, Florida State and North Carolina) and a 7-10 record against the Top 100. The single win came against Texas, which compares poorly to teams with a similar record against top competition (Northwestern, Miami, USF). Owns two horrible losses (at Clemson, Georgia Tech at home).

USF (19-13, 13-7 Big East, RPI: 53, SOS: 27, non-conf. SOS: 27)
Pros: Favorable computer numbers, quality wins against Cincinnati in Tampa and at Louisville, and a potential tiebreaking win over Seton Hall. Performed well in the Big East, though the schedule was comparatively soft.

Cons: Has a 2-9 record against the Top 50, 6-10 against the Top 100. Profile features three bad losses from early in the season (Old Dominion and Penn State in Springfield, at Auburn). Performed poorly away from home (6-11).

Seton Hall (20-12, 9-11 Big East, RPI: 65, SOS: 49, non-conf. SOS: 31)
Pros: Has three wins against the Top 50 (Georgetown, Connecticut and VCU (in Charleston)), also defeated West Virginia at home and won at Dayton. Overall record against the Top 100 is a respectable 7-9.

Cons: Finished poorly by losing seven of its last 12, including games against Rutgers and at DePaul. Lost at USF and to Northwestern in Charleston. Seven wins in 16 road/neutral games is also not helpful.

Drexel (27-6, 18-3 CAA, RPI: 71, SOS: 226, non-conf. SOS: 215)
Pros: Won 25 of 27 games to close the season, claiming the Colonial regular season title in the process. If the Committee values wins, the Dragons are in without a doubt. Owns four Top 100 wins (and three losses), though only the one against VCU came against a Top 50 team. Good road/neutral mark of 14-6.

Cons: Computer numbers are not attractive, thanks to a down CAA and weak non-league schedule. Went 2-4 to start season, when Chris Fouch was out or limited, with losses to Norfolk State and Delaware in that span.

First Four Out

Marshall (20-13, 12-8 C-USA, RPI: 42, SOS: 26, non-conf. SOS: 86)
Pros: Earned four Top 50 wins, including one at Cincinnati early in the season and two over Southern Mississippi, and six Top 100 wins (against 10 losses). Strong RPI and SOS numbers.

Cons: Lost at Tulsa and East Carolina, fell at home to UAB. Split with UCF and Belmont. Completely manhandled by Memphis in C-USA final. Road/neutral mark of 8-9 is merely respectable.

Dayton (20-12, 10-8 A-10, RPI: 79, SOS: 66, non-conf. SOS: 74)
Pros: A .500 record against the Top 50 and Top 100, with four Top 50 wins, including one at Temple. Defeated Alabama, Saint Louis, Seton Hall and Xavier at home.

Cons: RPI is a tad high. Owns a pair of truly bad losses (at Miami (Ohio) and Rhode Island at home) and questionable ones against Duquesne and Richmond. The Flyers' road/neutral mark of 6-8 leaves a little to be desired.

Mississippi (20-13, 10-9 SEC, RPI: 54, SOS: 48, non-conf. SOS: 33)
Pros: Victories over Alabama, Miami and Mississippi State, all at home. Decent out-of-conference schedule.

Cons: Road/neutral record of 8-10 is deceptive, as the Rebels best wins away from Oxford came against Tennessee in New Orleans and at Georgia and Arkansas. Mississippi also owns seven losses against the Top 50 and 12 against the Top 100, along with a bad loss at Auburn. Lost to Middle Tennessee, Dayton and LSU, though Murphy Holloway was out for those games.

Mississippi State (21-11, 8-9 SEC, RPI: 74, SOS: 71, non-conf. SOS: 54)
Pros: Has seven Top 100 wins and two against the Top 50 (at Vanderbilt, Alabama). Defeated West Virginia at home and Arizona in New York. Split with Mississippi.

Cons: Won just five of last 12. Lost to Georgia twice, as well as at Arkansas and Auburn. A 6-8 record away from home is not as good as it appears simply because the Bulldogs failed to beat an SEC West foe on the road.

Next Four Out

Iona (25-7, 16-4 MAAC, RPI: 41, SOS: 143, non-conf. SOS: 174)
Pros: Five wins against the Top 100, favorable RPI, excellent record away from home (15-6).

Cons: Two best wins came against Nevada and St. Joseph's, both of whom will likely be in the NIT. Has three losses to teams ranked 150+ in the RPI (Manhattan, at Siena, at Hofstra).

Washington (21-10, 14-5 Pac-12, RPI: 69, SOS: 87, non-conf. SOS: 100)
Pros: Pac-12 regular season champions, though that may not mean much this season. Has swept Arizona and split with Oregon, besting the Ducks in Seattle. Won nine of its final 12.

Cons: Has a 4-8 record against the Top 100, with no Top 50 wins. Lost at UCLA and was eliminated from Pac-12 Tournament as top seed by Oregon State. Owns an unimpressive 7-8 record in road/neutral games.

Miami (19-12, 10-8 ACC, RPI: 61, SOS: 43, non-conf. SOS: 52)
Pros: Owns victories over Duke (in Durham) and Florida State. Worst loss is at Maryland, who is just outside the Top 100.

Cons: Victory over UMass at home is the Hurricanes' only other one against a team in the Top 100 (against 11 losses). Won just six of 15 games away from Coral Gables.

Northwestern (18-13, 8-11 Big Ten, RPI: 60, SOS: 18, non-conf. SOS: 12)
Pros: Exceptionally strong schedule provides a boost, as do victories over Michigan State and Seton Hall (in Charleston). Worst loss came to Illinois (No. 93 in the RPI).

Cons: Failed to take advantage of the numerous opportunities handed to them, by going 1-10 against the Top 50 and 5-13 against the Top 100. Grabbing a few of them would have also likely improved a 7-8 record away from Evanston.

Also Considered

Arizona (23-11, 14-7 Pac-12, RPI: 72, SOS: 116, non-conf. SOS: 95)
Pros: Won at California to claim its only Top 50 win (against three losses), owns six total Top 100 wins (against nine losses), though three of those victims are on the edge of the list.

Cons: Swept by Washington and lost only meeting of the season with Oregon. Lost to Mississippi Sate in New York early in the campaign. Closed regular season with bad loss to Arizona State.

Tennessee (17-14, 10-7 SEC, RPI: 85, SOS: 31, non-conf. SOS: 44)
Pros: Four Top 50 wins, with all coming after Jarnell Stokes became eligible, three more against teams ranked between 51 and 100.

Cons: Quartet of bad losses (at Georgia, College of Charleston and Oakland, plus Austin Peay at home). Lost likely elimination game to Mississippi on Friday night. Flat out bad in road/neutral contests (3-11).

Oregon (22-9, 13-6 Pac-12, RPI: 64, SOS: 92, non-conf. SOS: 106)
Pros: Five Top 100 wins, including single victories over Arizona, Colorado and Washington. Only one bad RPI loss, at home against archrival Oregon State. Record away from Eugene is decent at 7-6.

Cons: Has no Top 50 wins, though losses at Vanderbilt, against BYU in Salt Lake City and at home to Virginia all happened before Devoe Joseph became eligible. Swept by Cal and was unable to beat Colorado and Washington twice.

As you can see, each of these teams have selling points and significant issues. In a few hours, we will know what specific combinations the Selection Committee agreed upon. I'll have one last projection before they reveal the finished product at 6 p.m. ET. Expect it between 30 minutes and one hour beforehand.