clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

2017 ACC football power rankings: Will we finally get our FSU-Miami title game?

Now that Bill’s studied every ACC team, here’s how he stacks them up. Also, here are some charts and stuff!

NCAA Football: Florida State at Miami
We might finally get the Miami-FSU title game we’ve been promised for 10 years.
Steve Mitchell-USA TODAY Sports

At the end of each conference previews run-through, I take a look at how I perceive the conference's balance of power heading into the season. This is in no way based on schedules, so they are not predictions. This is just how I would rank the teams after writing thousands of words about each of them. So far we’ve done the Sun Belt, C-USA, MAC, MWC, AAC, Big 12, Pac-12, and Big Ten.

Bill C’s ACC power rankings

Here’s a link to every team’s data, and each team’s name below is linked to its preview.

Tier 1

1. Florida State
2. Clemson

This part was pretty easy to anticipate, I’m guessing. The two teams that have combined for 138 wins and six conference titles over the past six seasons are going to start out ahead of the pack. And I think it’s pretty safe to say that, because of the quarterback position, the Noles are the more trustworthy team out of the gates.

Clemson’s not only having to replace its best quarterback ever; the Tigers start the year with games against Auburn, Louisville, and Virginia Tech in September. That will either kickstart a surprising repeat run or position them into Rebuild Season mode. They still host FSU, though, so that could make the division race fun.

Tier 2

3. Louisville

The new defensive coordinator hire makes me nervous, but Louisville will basically start 2017 with all the same strengths and weaknesses as last year. Fourth-year Petrino teams tend to undergo massive breakthroughs; it would be a surprise if the Cardinals were too much better than last year, but they’re still going to be very good.

Tier 3

4. NC State
5. Miami
6. Virginia Tech
7. Pitt
8. North Carolina
9. Georgia Tech

Here’s where things get interesting. The ACC rose to (or near) the top of college football last year, in part because the conference’s middle class was awesome. But Miami, Virginia Tech, Pitt, UNC, and Georgia Tech are also replacing their starting quarterbacks. Some of them will end up just fine with their replacements, but it’s hard to know who.

Within this pack, I think Miami starts out ahead. And if the Canes have a QB, they shoot to third in the conference, at least. Quite the if.

So yes, in the 14th year of Miami’s ACC membership, and in the 13th year of the ACC title game, we might finally get the Miami-FSU conference title game the league planned for (by creating awful divisions) long ago.

Meanwhile, I find myself trusting NC State an alarming amount. This will end badly.

The top four teams, all in the ACC Atlantic. Divisions are so, so stupid.

Tier 4

10. Syracuse
11. Duke
12. Wake Forest
13. Boston College
14. Virginia

Syracuse needs more damn defensive talent, Duke needs another year, Wake needs a little more offensive talent, BC needs a lot more offensive talent, and ... I’m just punting on Virginia until 2018.

How does S&P+ see things?

Here’s how my statistical system has the ACC laid out for 2017, with zero equating to an average FBS team. (You can find full 2017 S&P+ projections here.)

2017 projected standings (per S&P+)

Projected conference wins, with overall wins in parentheses.

  1. Florida State 6.5 (9.5)
  2. Clemson 5.9 (9.3)
  3. Louisville 5.5 (9.1)
  4. NC State 3.9 (6.6)
  5. Wake Forest 2.7 (5.0)
  6. Syracuse 2.6 (5.3)
  7. Boston College 1.9 (4.1)
  1. Miami 4.9 (8.1)
  2. Virginia Tech 4.7 (8.1)
  3. Pitt 4.2 (6.7)
  4. Georgia Tech 4.1 (6.6)
  5. North Carolina 3.6 (6.3)
  6. Duke 2.8 (5.4)
  7. Virginia 2.6 (5.0)

How these teams looked in 2016

ACC 2016

ACC offenses heading into 2017

ACC offenses

The ACC had a lot of nicely balanced teams last year, plus three or four more that were at least good at either offense or defense. This year’s offenses will regress.

Best 2017 offensive players by team (best overall in bold):

  • BC: WR Jeff Smith
  • Clemson: WR Deon Cain
  • Duke: QB Daniel Jones
  • Florida State: QB Deondre Francois
  • Georgia Tech: Well, it was FB Dedrick Mills, but he was dismissed in August
  • Louisville: QB Lamar Jackson
  • Miami: WR Ahmmon Richards
  • NC State: OG Tony Adams
  • North Carolina: OT Bentley Spain
  • Pitt: RB Quadree Henderson
  • Syracuse: WR Steve Ishmael
  • Virginia: WR Olamide Zaccheaus
  • Virginia Tech: WR Cam Phillips
  • Wake Forest: TE Cam Serigne

Remember Lamar? He’s still pretty good.

NCAA Football: Citrus Bowl-Louisiana State vs Louisville
Lamar Jackson
Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports

ACC defenses

ACC defenses

The ACC has more often than not been a defense-friendly conference. Should be the case again.

Best 2017 defensive players by team (best overall in bold):

  • BC: DE Harold Landry
  • Clemson: DT Dexter Lawrence
  • Duke: LB Ben Humphreys
  • Florida State: FS Derwin James
  • Georgia Tech: CB Lance Austin
  • Louisville: DE James Hearns
  • Miami: LB Shaquille Quarterman
  • NC State: DE Bradley Chubb
  • North Carolina: CB M.J. Stewart
  • Pitt: CB Avonte Maddox
  • Syracuse: FS Antwan Cordy
  • Virginia: DE Andrew Brown
  • Virginia Tech: LB Tremaine Edmunds
  • Wake Forest: DE Duke Ejiofor

Really, this is a tie between Landry and all-everything Derwin James. But in this instance, tie goes to the guy who didn’t get hurt last year.

NCAA Football: Florida State at Boston College
Harold Landry
Mark L. Baer-USA TODAY Sports