clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

The SEC and Pac-12 vs. the world: The dream matchup of 2013 All-Americans

Let's take the top two conferences in the land and square them off against the rest of the country.

Mike Zarrilli, Getty, and Matthew Emmons, USA Today

We don't know which conference is college football's best, but we do know the two best. The SEC just completed a seven-year title streak, and statistics show the Pac-12 was the most balanced conference in 2013. So what if we combined them?

If we create an all-star team using just the Pac-12 and the SEC, would it be better than an all-star team made up of players from every other conference? Let's check it out. We'll be using a combination of the consensus All-American team and our own All-American team to select the players for these squads.

Quarterback

SEC/Pac-12: Johnny Manziel, Texas A&M

World: Jameis Winston, Florida State

The two Heisman winners each blessed college football with more than 4,000 yards and 40 touchdowns. One led his team to a perfect 14-0 record and a national title victory, but that's more a team achievement than an individual accomplishment.

Manziel had the disadvantage of having to overcome a very bad defense, but Winston made as many plays and fewer mistakes throughout the year. He finished with the country's highest passer rating by more than 10 points.

(Note: Alabama's AJ McCarron had more first-team All-America honors than Manziel, believe it or not, but Manziel is listed as the second-teamer behind Winston on most teams.)

Advantage: World

Running back

SEC/Pac-12: Ka'Deem Carey, Arizona

World: Andre Williams, Boston College

Williams may have finished with more yards than Carey, but Arizona's back was far more consistent -- he ran for at least 119 yards in every game, while Williams had four performances in double digits. Carey also had his best games on the biggest stage, with 206 yards and four touchdowns in an upset victory over Oregon.

Plus he averaged 6.3 yards per carry with two touchdowns in the Wildcats' win over Williams' Eagles in the Independence Bowl.

Advantage: SEC/Pac-12

Wide receivers

SEC/Pac-12: Mike Evans, Texas A&M and Brandin Cooks, Oregon State

World: Davante Adams, Fresno State and Sammy Watkins, Clemson

Cooks, the Biletnikoff Award winner, led the nation with 1,730 receiving yards, with 16 touchdowns and over 130 yards per game. Evans, Manziel's top target, averaged a ridiculous 20.2 yards per catch with 12 touchdowns and played his best in big games against Alabama and Auburn.

Adams bested everyone in receptions and touchdowns, but he played against significantly easier competition, and while Watkins had a very good season, it doesn't hold up to Evans or Cooks.

Evans averaged 14.2 yards per target, while the other three averaged about 11 each.

Advantage: SEC/Pac-12

Tight end

SEC/Pac-12: Austin Seferian-Jenkins, Washington

World: Jace Amaro, Texas Tech

Seferian-Jenkins may have the Mackey Award, physical advantage, and more NFL potential. But Amaro was far and away the top tight end in the country this season, with his 106 catches and 1,352 yards ranking among the top receivers, let alone tight ends. Some don't consider Amaro a tight end -- but Texas Tech does, and so do we.

Advantage: World

Tackles

SEC/Pac-12: Jake Matthews, Texas A&M and Cyrus Kouandjio, Alabama

World: Cameron Erving, Florida State and Taylor Lewan, Michigan

Out of the four schools listed, Alabama had the best run blocking (No. 6 in Football Outsiders' Adjusted Line Yards) and Michigan had the worst (No. 110), so that quickly sways things in the SEC/Pac-12's favor. The big difference comes out in sacks allowed -- Alabama gave up 17 and Texas A&M allowed 20, while Florida State gave up 33 and Michigan allowed 36.

The World team could be hurt by the inclusion of Lewan, who was a part of one of the worst offensive lines in all of football and seems to be on award lists due in part to his name recognition. He could still be a top-10 NFL Draft pick, but so could both of the SEC's tackles.

Advantage: SEC/Pac-12

Guards

SEC/Pac-12: David Yankey, Stanford and Xavier Su'a-Filo, UCLA

World: Cyril Richardson, Baylor and Ryan Groy, Wisconsin

Richardson could be the best of the three, but Yankey and Su'a-Filo each come close. Baylor had the most explosive offense in the nation, and Wisconsin was close behind (with Stanford and UCLA each in the top 35). But our Matthew Fairburn ranks Su'a-Filo as the country's best guard, with Yankey third behind Richardson.

Advantage: SEC/Pac-12

Center

SEC/Pac-12: Travis Swanson, Arkansas

World: Bryan Stork, Florida State

Swanson is very good, and the Razorbacks' line was better than you'd think (one of only 14 to rank in the top 35 in both of Football Outsiders' major pass-blocking and run-blocking stats). But Stork won the Rimington Trophy, annually given to the top center in the nation, and helped clear the way for Jameis Winston, Devonta Freeman, and the rest of the Seminoles' vaunted attack en route to a national title.

The deciding factor? Swanson's offensive line featured two freshmen starters, while Stork had the benefit of four upperclassmen. Swanson also ranks higher on Fairburn's centers list.

Advantage: SEC/Pac-12

Defensive ends

SEC/Pac-12: Michael Sam, Missouri and Leonard Williams, USC

World: Jackson Jeffcoat, Texas and Vic Beasley, Clemson

Sam was the star of a Missouri defense that lived on disrupting plays and causing turnovers, and Williams was one of the most consistent presences for the up-and-down Trojans, but Hendricks Award-winner Jeffcoat and Beasley both had incredible seasons in their respective shades of orange. The World team holds strong edges in both tackles for a loss (42 to 31.5) and sacks (26 to 16.5), so this one's an easy call.

Advantage: World

Defensive tackles

SEC/Pac-12: Will Sutton, Arizona State and Kelcy Quarles, South Carolina

World: Aaron Donald, Pittsburgh and Timmy Jernigan, Florida State

Sutton was able to eat up space and make room for his teammates, but his production was significantly down from his junior season. Both he and Quarles turned in 13.5 tackles for loss.

Production was no problem for Donald, who came within four of Jason Babin's single-season tackles for loss record (posting 28.5). Jernigan was one of the key cogs of the title-winning Florida State defense, which led the nation in scoring defense.

Advantage: World

Linebackers

SEC/Pac-12: Anthony Barr, UCLA, C.J. Mosley, Alabama and Trent Murphy, Stanford

World: Ryan Shazier, Ohio State, Khalil Mack, Buffalo and Chris Borland, Wisconsin

Barr and Murphy were two of the most dynamic players in the nation, each finishing with more than 20 tackles for a loss and 10 sacks (while Barr tied for the nation's lead with six fumbles forced). Mosley might have been the best overall defensive player in the country, leading a fierce Alabama unit from the middle linebacker spot.

Mack also might have been the best pure defensive talent in the nation and is projected to be a top-five pick in the NFL Draft, and Shazier compares well with Murphy. But there's a significant fall-off from Barr to Borland.

Advantage: SEC/Pac-12

Cornerbacks

SEC/Pac-12: Ifo Ekpre-Olomu, Oregon and Vernon Hargreaves III, Florida

World: Darqueze Dennard, Michigan State and LaMarcus Joyner, Florida State

The World team gets the two most frequent first-team All-American corners, so that's a decisive advantage.

Ekpre-Olomu and Hargreaves III were often third-team selections. Hargreaves was one of the best freshmen in the nation and was a key member of one of the best secondaries in the nation, while Ekpre-Olomu showed his talents in both pass coverage and tackling.

But Dennard won the Jim Thorpe Award and had four interceptions on the third-ranked passing defense in the country, based on yardage. Joyner was all over the field for the Seminoles -- the top-ranked passing defense -- and finished the year with seven tackles for a loss, three fumbles forced, and two interceptions.

Advantage: World

Safeties

SEC/Pac-12: Ha Ha Clinton-Dix, Alabama and Deone Bucannon, Washington State

World: Ahmad Dixon, Baylor and Jimmie Ward, Northern Illinois

Dixon helped lead a very strong Baylor defense, and Ward was a big-time part of Northern Illinois's undefeated regular season.

But Bucannon was an absolute force for the Cougars. He led the conference in tackles and interceptions and put together the best individual-statistics season of any safety in the country. And Clinton-Dix's season was cut short by a two-game suspension, but he still managed to make a difference for the dominating Tide defense, picking off two passes. Fairburn ranks him as the country's best safety.

Advantage: SEC/Pac-12

Kicker

SEC/Pac-12: Marshall Morgan, Georgia

World: Roberto Aguayo, Florida State

Morgan may have hit 22 of 24 field goals and all 47 extra points, but Winston wasn't the only redshirt freshman to make a big impact for the national title-winning Seminoles. Aguayo hit 21 of his 22 field goal attempts in his first season of play, including all 94 (94!) extra point attempts.

Advantage: World

Punter

SEC/Pac-12: Drew Kaser, Texas A&M

World: Tom Hornsey, Memphis

Kaser had the higher per-punt average (47.4), but because of Texas A&M's prolific offense he only punted the ball 3.7 times per game -- fourth-to-last in the nation. Hornsey, a four-year starter, won the Ray Guy and averaged a career-best 45.2 yards per punt on more than five kicks per game.

Advantage: World

Final tally

Tie. No, we didn't do that on purpose. So, what do you think? (The only real takeaway from this? We'd love to see this game.)

Photos: Crystal LoGiudice/USA Today, Mark J. Rebilas/USA Today, Kevork Djansezian/Getty

More from SB Nation college football:

Counting down the 100 best CFB games of 2013: The full list

Super Bowl 42 rooting guide for college football fans

The Florida State process: How Jimbo Fisher built a new champion

Yes, there’s a GIF of Nick Saban dancing

College football news | NFL Draft early entry winners and losers

Long CFB reads | The death of a college football player