clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Here's what 6-team, 8-team, and 24-team 2016 College Football Playoffs would look like

Good morning! This is the Read Option, your daily college football newsletter. Sign up for this in your inbox!

The College Football Playoff will expand at some point. Officials started talking about it publicly before it was even played, no one in sports has ever demonstrated a tendency against adding lucrative stuff, and the New Year's Six bowl structure has already elevated six different bowls to semifinal status. Giving Playoff duties to more than two of those games per year would not be a huge challenge.

Here's what it'd look like if we did six teams, with first-round byes for the top two seeds and automatic bids for all five power conferences, meaning Big 12 champ Oklahoma would jump No. 6 Michigan and get a rematch against Ohio State. (We should pay players money for playing 12 to 16 games of revenue-generating football, which might require paying college coaches as if they're not NFL coaches and/or not building nine-figure facilities.)

You could also give the sixth spot to the top-ranked mid-major champion instead of an auto-bid, if you wanted to avoid eventual BCS-style lawsuits and be able to claim that every team definitely has a path to a national title. That would make Oklahoma No. 5 and Western Michigan No. 6 this year. This is close to a totally fair plan. Power 5 teams would better know their Playoff requirements (just be the best in your conference, though you could sub in Penn State for Ohio State this year if you wanted only conference champs, meaning non-conference games no longer matter at all), and no mid-majors would be eliminated before Week 1 begins.

Here's an eight-team plan that gives automatic bids to each Power 5 champ and the top-ranked mid-major, plus two at-large spots. If you want all six New Year's bowls to host Playoff games every year, here you go (this year, it could even have a traditional Big Ten vs. Pac-12 Rose Bowl). This is also pretty good, but it sure would be nice if it compensated players for their additional wear-and-tear and academic disruptions. On Wednesday, NCAA president Mark Emmert came out in support of a plan like this, but he doesn't have any say here.

And here's a full, 24-team, FCS-style tournament that includes automatic bids for every FBS conference champion (I ranked the last few mid-majors, who aren't in the Playoff rankings, by S&P+ rankings). The FCS level manages to cram all this in without sprawling into mid-January, so it'd have to get going without a month-long December delay. And it'd make a ton of money, which would be nice to see go to players and not all to multi-millionaires.

Brackets via

CFB in your inbox, everyday, for free!

Get an original mini-column on the college football thing of the day, plus news, links, and fun stuff!


Spencer Hall on Lamar Jackson is pretty good, as is Spencer Hall on anything.

Lane Kiffin could be Houston's head coach by the time you read this, but he's not right now.

Alabama's suddenly leaking QB transfers. Things are fine going forward, with Jalen Hurts only a freshman and another blue-chip committed, but depth is getting perilous. Hey, look! Alabama almost has one problem!!!

Tom Herman stunted on them via business cards, showing the only thing that's changed about his since 20 years ago has been his job title.

Tweets by USF players show not too many hard feelings about Willie Taggart taking the Oregon job.

Jim Harbaugh plans to watch Florida State's fiery spear-planting like a fan.

Nevada reportedly has a head coach: Arizona State assistant Jay Norvell.

Commit of the day: four-star ATH Ambry Thomas to Michigan.