clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Look at the March Madness committee. Suuure you want a bigger College Football Playoff?

New, comments

Good morning! This is the Read Option, your daily college football newsletter. Sign up for this in your inbox!

Kevin Jairaj-USA TODAY Sports

Just one of many baffling decisions made by the NCAA Tournament's selection committee this time around was the inclusion of Tulsa:

Tulsa has to be the most out-of-left field pick I've ever seen. The team's own players assumed they were going to the NIT. ESPN bracketologist Joe Lunardi called the decision "indefensible by every known standard." The Bracket Matrix compiles 59 brackets from people considered to be bracket experts; zero picked Tulsa.

Tulsa was not an NCAA-worthy team by any conceivable measure. The Golden Hurricane didn't have a great record, going 20-12 with a 12-6 record in the middling American. Their RPI was 61, well below what the committee generally accepts from an at-large bid, and 58th in Ken Pomeroy's rankings. They didn't even pass the "eye test," losing twice by sizable margins to a trashy Memphis.

There's plenty more on other teams in there. But the big takeaway for college football fans might be that -- phew -- we only have to worry about how our committee ranks four or so teams (depending on how much you care about the New Year's Six), rather than 70-ish. For now.

Ranking teams is hard, and explaining rankings is hard. Ranking any more than a handful of obvious teams (which football got in 2015) to satisfaction is nearly impossible. Doing all that while trying to stick to weird rubrics (the Playoff committee doesn't use margin of victory, except when it kind of does!) is gonna mean justified anger we can set our calendars to.

Even though the Playoff committee's methods should be more evolved than the NCAA's, they're not significantly more modernized, and our committee is certainly no better at explaining its choices in 90-second TV bursts. The extreme annoyance we all feel as Jeff Long breezes through a description of the process? That would intensify magnificently with a bigger Playoff. More slots to fill would mean more odd choices explained in odd ways.

Just one more reason not to expand it. That and the athletes playing more and more football without getting any more of a cut of all the money, and all that.

Bill C team of the day: Hawaii, which has to travel about 10,000 miles before its first home game, then play another Power 5 team on the road. Nothing easy.


Get one roundup of college football stories, rumors, game breakdowns, and Jim Harbaugh oddity in your inbox every morning.

Bud Elliott has many morsels of interest to Big 12 fans from The Opening's Dallas camp, including an unknown New Mexico recruit whose explosive workout earned him sudden interest from loads of big schools.

Players having to lose scores of pounds in a few months is just one of many reasons recruiting to service academies is so hard, and the stories of the players who do it will probably inspire you to, like, stand during breakfast instead of sitting.

Expect another three-team race in the Sun Belt, based on these power rankings by the man who's extensively previewed every team in it.

Penn State's QB battle is one of the nation's most complicated, and not even James Franklin implies he has any idea what's gonna happen.

Will Muschamp seems pretty straightforward about South Carolina's strengths and weaknesses as spring ball begins.

Washington went 0-12 in 2008, then didn't win more than seven games until 2013. So here's UW Dawg Pound on the joy of finally turning the corner.

What do you do if you're a non-power team that doesn't really have a rival?

Burnt Orange Nation is unconvinced by the latest proclamations that QB Tyrone Swoopes has turned the corner.

The legal battle to release the video of Oklahoma's Joe Mixon punching a woman is still developing.

You can apparently buy the Oregon Duck's motorcycle on Craigslist for $25,000?

Want more college football all the time? Let's be friends on Facebook, @SBNationCFB and Instagram. Also, sign up for our college football recruiting newsletter by Bud Elliott.