clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

The 73-win Warriors didn't win the title. Who was college football's Golden State?

New, comments

Good morning! This is the Read Option, your daily college football newsletter. Sign up for this in your inbox!

Getty

On Sunday night, LeBron James sat surrounded by his three children, a victory cigar, and the Larry O'Brien trophy. When asked about the 73-win Warriors, he praised them and dropped a plain fact that still counted as a jab right to the heart, calling them "the greatest regular season team ever."

Something crazy happened in the NBA. When something crazy happens in sports, it's a safe bet that something similar has happened in college football. So let's see if we have anybody in recent memory who can compare.

These aren't the best teams that didn't win titles (here's a list of the best 25 recent teams from that group, according to the numbers), because you can lose in any week of your season and still go on to win the title, though you won't be the best ever.

And these aren't teams that just plain got snubbed, because that happened every few years until the BCS, and even sometimes thereafter.

These are teams that entered the championship (or pre-BCS equivalent) undefeated and prepared to stake claims among the greatest teams ever, then lost. We'll go back to 1980, in part because that's about how far Bill Connelly's gone in his statistical analysis of old seasons and because that covers either recent memory or entire lifetimes for me and probably you.

I think there are only two or three serious recent candidates, but here are 19 teams since 1980 that didn't suffer a loss until the final game. If I missed somebody, I apologize.

Personal ranking Team Record AP No. 1 since ... Bowl loss Post-bowl S&P+ rating
1 2011 LSU 13-1 Sept. 25 21-0 in rematch vs. No. 2 Alabama 28.7
2 2005 USC 12-1 Preseason 41-38 to Vince Young and friends 29.7
3 1983 Nebraska 12-1 Preseason 31-30 to No. 5 Miami after a moment of doomed valor 24.2
4 2002 Miami 12-1 Preseason (except one week when Oklahoma jumped up) A controversial 31-24 in 2OT to No. 2 Ohio State 21.1
5 2004 Oklahoma 12-1 Never (No. 2 entire season) 55-19 to No. 1 USC 21.3
6 2006 Ohio State 12-1 Preseason 41-14 to No. 2 Florida in the game that gave us "SEC speed" 21.3
7 2015 Clemson 14-1 Nov. 1 45-40 to No. 2 Alabama 27.4
8 1986 Miami 11-1 Sept. 28 14-10 to No. 2 Penn State after seven turnovers 24
9 1987 Oklahoma 11-1 Preseason, basically (Nebraska jumped up for one week, then lost to OU) 20-14 to No. 2 Miami 18.9
10 1999 Virginia Tech 11-1 Never (top two since Nov. 7) 46-29 to No. 1 FSU after a comeback and collapse 20.6
11 1996 Florida State 11-1 Nov. 31 (top three all season) 52-20 in rematch vs. No. 3 Florida 22.8
12 2009 Texas 13-1 Never (top two almost entire season) 37-21 to No. 1 Alabama after losing QB Colt McCoy early 23.2
13 1995 Florida 12-1 Never (top three since Sept. 30) 62-24 to Tommie Frazier and friends 23.1
14 2010 Oregon 12-1 October 10, until the final BCS 22-19 to No. 1 Auburn, though Michael Dyer was down 14.7
15 1993 Nebraska 11-1 Not even top four until Nov. 7 18-16 to No. 1 Florida State 22.3
16 1989 Colorado 11-1 Nov. 19 21-6 to No. 4 Notre Dame 21.5
17 2012 Notre Dame 12-1 Nov. 18 42-14 to No. 2 Alabama 21.7
18 1982 Georgia 11-1 Nov. 7 27-23 to No. 2 Penn State 15.4
19 1985 Penn State 11-1 Nov. 10 25-10 to No. 3 Oklahoma 12.3

The 2011 Tigers later became punchlines for failing to cross midfield against Bama until the game was decided, and their offensive struggles in that game would color how we've talked about Les Miles teams ever since.

But look at the resume. LSU beat eight teams that were ranked at the time (the highest number in at least 39 years). Is that a little dubious, since final rankings are better indicators of team quality? Okay. LSU beat final No. 1 Alabama by three, final No. 4 Oregon by 13, final No. 5 Arkansas by 24, SEC East champion Georgia by 32, and the about-to-drop-70-on-Clemson West Virginia by 26.

Otherwise, they splattered folks. The Tide were the only team to play LSU within a score.

The S&P+ number in that table was lowered by the bowl loss, but even that tells part of the tale. According to S&P+, the 2011 LSU that lost by 21 to Alabama would still be a slight favorite against, say, the 2013 Florida State that broke scoring records and won the national title.

Now imagine how good we perceived LSU as being before that single loss. In November, ESPN's Chris Low said, "LSU has a chance to put a bow on what would be the most impressive season in SEC history."

I don't think we were about to stamp LSU as the greatest team ever, like we were with the Warriors, but college football has a much more crowded conversation than any other major American sport, due to its decades of total disorganization. With a win over Bama or Oklahoma State in the BCS, LSU would've immediately entered the debate.

2005 USC is also easy to argue as a potential all-time team, but those Trojans' top two wins were only ("only") final No. 9 Notre Dame and final No. 10 Oregon. If we include bowl games, the '05 Trojans probably top the '11 Tigers, but this is about who was riding the highest Warriors-style wave before the postseason.

What do you think? Who's your college football Golden State?

SIGN UP TO GET THIS IN YOUR INBOX!

Get one roundup of college football stories, rumors, game breakdowns, and Big 12 hysteria in your inbox every morning.