clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Mike Woodson wonders if Beno Udrih 'had to' pass to J.R. Smith

New, comments

Mike Woodson has a question: Did Beno have to?

Tom Szczerbowski-USA TODAY Sport

The New York Knicks are still mulling over J.R. Smith's decision to take an untimely three-point attempt at the end of their late-game collapse to the Houston Rockets. Mike Woodson spoke with media prior to the Knicks' game against the Dallas Mavericks and said Smith "went blank" but went on to ask a simple question: Did Beno Udrih have to pass him the ball? Via Al Iannazzone of Newsday:

Did Beno have to? In case you missed the "infamous" play, here's what went down:

Didbenohaveto_medium

The shot clock had turned off and the game was down to the final possession after Tyson Chandler retrieved the offensive rebound. Chandler passed out to Udrih, who then passed it to Smith alone at the top of the arc. It's not uncommon for teams to reset their offense at the top, but it is uncommon for a team to take a shot that early in a final-possession situation.

Aaron Brooks made two free-throws on the other end and Houston wound up with a win after the gaffe from Smith.

Of course, using the aforementioned logic, did Chandler have to pass to Udrih? More importantly, if a coach doesn't trust a player to have the ball in their hands late in the game and wonders aloud if his teammates should have passed to him, why is he in the game to begin with? It's not just the terrible timing of the shot, but Smith admitted after the game he was unaware of the score and thought the Knicks were down two:

Just another day for the Knicks, who have lost four of their last five games.

More from SB Nation NBA:

O'Donnell: Andrew Bynum's irreconcilable differences with basketball

The Hook: Sixers, Suns show off the new 1-year rebuild

Joe Johnson keeps killing teams at the buzzer

Eberhardt: What do NBA assistant coaches do during games?

Prada's Pictures: The Knicks' sad, terrible defense