clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

NFL preseason 2015 results and scores: Brian Hoyer, Ryan Mallett begin QB battle

Brian Hoyer and Ryan Mallett got their quarterback battle started against the San Francisco 49ers on Saturday.

Bob Levey/Getty Images

The Houston Texans got their quarterback battle underway in their preseason opener against the San Francisco 49ers on Saturday, and after one game ... there's no clear leader. After making a change to their unofficial depth chart to remove the "or" between Brian Hoyer and Ryan Mallett in the starter column, the team went with Hoyer to start Saturday's game.

Hoyer only attempted four passes on the day, two of which were completed. Fortunately, one of those completions was a 58-yard touchdown to Cecil Shorts III, and he finished 2 of 4 for 67 yards. The Texans took him out after that initial drive, and let Mallett take over through the half.

Mallett also played quite well, completing 10 of 11 passes for 90 yards, with no touchdowns but also no interceptions. Neither quarterback was sacked, and the Texans have to feel encouraged by this one. If these guys continue playing well and make the starting decision a tough call, it will be a good problem to have for the Texans.

3 things we learned from Saturday's games

Winston struggles in debut

Tampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback Jameis Winston made his NFL debut on Saturday and it wasn't pretty. He struggled through most of the first half, missing his receivers and looking uncomfortable in the pocket. He had a bad interception, which you can see below:

He did do one big thing, though, when he rushed for a touchdown to end the second quarter. He managed to finish strong, but it was ultimately a tough game for him. He finished 9 of 19 for 131 yards with no touchdowns through the air and an interception, along with four carries for 18 yards and a touchdown.

The other prominent rookie quarterback, No. 2 overall draft pick Marcus Mariota, made his debut with the Tennessee Titans on Friday. It was a decent debut, with Mariota looking good on some throws but bad on others -- particularly his interception and the fumble that was returned for a touchdown.

49ers a mixed bag on defense

The San Francisco 49ers underwent a mountain of change this offseason, with a new coaching staff and Patrick Willis, Justin Smith, Chris Borland and Anthony Davis all retiring. The first three of those players are defenders, so seeing how the first-team defense plays was of particular interest on Saturday. It went poorly.

It's worth noting that it wasn't the complete starting defense, with guys like NaVorro Bowman and Michael Wilhoite sitting out. Still, it wasn't an encouraging start for a team that has a whole lot to prove this season. San Francisco's defense gave up big chunks of yardage in Saturday's game, and that was already a problem last season. They'll need to make some adjustments heading into their next preseason game.

Right tackle injuries for everyone


Get all kinds of NFL stories, rumors, game coverage, and inane comments from the NFL media in your inbox every day.

It was a rough day for right tackles across the league. First, Minnesota Vikings right tackle Phil Loadholt went down with an injury early and had to be carted off the field against the Buccaneers. Unfortunately, it quickly came out that Loadholt had suffered a torn Achilles, which will effectively end his 2015-16 season.

Then it was Demar Dotson of the Buccaneers who went down. Dotson is one of the top starting right tackles in the league, but he left late in the half with a left knee injury. Dotson was playing longer than expected as the Buccaneers were trying to give Winston more time with the starters. Finally, Chiefs right tackle Jeff Allen, who was only named the starting right tackle recently, left the game with a knee injury and was declared out for the game by Kansas City.

Final scores

Houston Texans 23, San Francisco 49ers 10

Battle Red Blog recapNiners Nation recap

Houston is likely pleased with the results thus far with its quarterback battle. The Texans also have to like Cecil Shorts creating that separation to get a long touchdown -- it was his only catch on the day. Running back Alfred Blue played quite well, carrying the ball nine times for 59 yards. Given Arian Foster's injury, that's a great sign for them. For the 49ers, they saw strong play out of backup quarterback Blaine Gabbert, but the starting offense failed to get going. Rugby league convert Jarryd Hayne looked great as a running back and as a returner though, which is definitely good news after Frank Gore left over the offseason.

Minnesota Vikings 26, Tampa Bay Buccaneers 16

Daily Norseman recapBucs Nation recap

We already covered Winston's night above -- it wasn't great by any stretch of the imagination. But Winston did have a big completion to Vincent Jackson, and he did have the touchdown run. Behind him, Mike Glennon performed well, completing 9 of 17 passes for 98 yards. The Vikings got good play out of starter Teddy Bridgewater, who completed 7 of 8 passes for 86 yards. Backup Shaun Hill tossed two touchdown passes, one of which went to underperforming wide receiver Cordarrelle Patterson. With the Hall of Fame Game, the Vikings have now won two preseason contests, though the loss of Loadholt is a big concern.

Kansas City Chiefs 34, Arizona Cardinals 19

Arrowhead Pride recapRevenge of the Birds recap

The Chiefs' offense got out to a shaky start, with starting quarterback Alex Smith throwing an interception. He finished 6 for 10 with 42 yards and the pick. Backup Chase Daniel fared quite a bit better, throwing three touchdowns, while wide receiver Fred Williams managed six receptions for 82 yards and a touchdown. For the Cardinals, Carson Palmer looked effective as usual, completing all four of his passes for 77 yards. Most importantly, the Cardinals didn't allow Palmer to get sacked. Keeping him protected will be the prime objective this season, and they did that on Saturday.